ADR-282: Decentraland Inspector

content/ADR-282-inspector.md

@@ -0,0 +1,306 @@
+---
+adr: 282
+date: 2025-01-17
+title: Decentraland Inspector
+authors:
+  - cazala
+status: Final
+type: Standards Track
+spdx-license: CC0-1.0
+---
+
+# Abstract
+
+The `@dcl/inspector` package implements a scene editor interface for Decentraland, built on React and TypeScript. It provides a modular architecture that can be integrated into different environments through well-defined RPC interfaces and abstractions.
+
+# Core Components
+
+## Entity Hierarchy
+
+A React component that renders and manages the scene's entity tree. It:
+
+- Uses the ECS SDK to track entity relationships and components
+- Manages special entities: `ROOT`, `PLAYER`, `CAMERA`
+- Implements entity operations through the SDK components API
+- Supports entity icons based on component composition (e.g., smart items, custom items, tiles)
+- Uses a generic `Tree` component for rendering hierarchical data
+
+### Component Inspector
+
+Handles component editing through specialized inspectors:
+
+Component-specific inspectors include:
+
+- `TransformInspector`: Position, rotation, and scale
+- `GltfInspector`: 3D model configuration
+- `MaterialInspector`: Material properties and textures
+- `ActionInspector`: Smart item action configuration
+- `TriggerInspector`: Smart item trigger setup
+- `StatesInspector`: Smart item state management
+- `TextShapeInspector`: Text rendering properties
+- `AudioSourceInspector`: Sound configuration
+- `VideoPlayerInspector`: Video playback settings
+- `NftShapeInspector`: NFT display configuration
+- `AnimatorInspector`: Animation controls
+- `PointerEventsInspector`: Interaction handling
+- `CounterInspector`: Value tracking
+- `VisibilityComponentInspector`: Display controls
+- `MeshColliderInspector`: Collision properties
+- `MeshRendererInspector`: Rendering settings
+
+**Features:**
+
+- Dynamically loads inspectors based on attached components
+- Supports both single and multi-entity selection
+- Implements basic/advanced view modes through `Config` component
+- Uses React hooks for component state management
+
+### Level Editor
+
+3D scene visualization and manipulation:
+
+- Integrates with the ECS engine for real-time updates
+- Implements transform gizmos using Babylon.js (position, rotation, scale)
+- Handles drag-and-drop through the DataLayer API
+- Manages camera controls and viewport state using Babylon.js scene management
+- Uses Babylon.js for 3D rendering and scene manipulation
+
+### Asset Management
+
+The Assets panel provides access to three main sources of content:
+
+1. **Local Assets**
+
+   - Shows project-specific resources (models, textures, sounds)
+   - Provides direct access to files in the project's directory
+   - Supports importing new assets from local filesystem
+   - Manages asset organization within the project structure
+
+2. **Custom Items**
+
+   - Displays user-created reusable items
+   - Items can be created by selecting entities in the scene
+   - Stores items with their complete configuration (components, resources)
+   - Supports operations like rename, delete, and reuse
+   - Items can be either static or interactive (smart items)
+
+3. **Asset Packs**
+
+   - Provides access to official Decentraland items
+   - Includes both static and smart items
+   - Organized in themed collections (cyberpunk, fantasy, etc.)
+   - Items are distributed via the `@dcl/asset-packs` package
+   - Available through CDN at builder-items.decentraland.org
+
+Additional functionality includes:
+
+- Asset import interface for adding new resources
+- Asset renaming capabilities
+- Custom item creation workflow
+- Drag-and-drop support for scene placement
+
+# Integration Architecture
+
+## Data Layer RPC
+
+The Data Layer has two implementations:
+
+1. **Local (In-Memory):**
+
+   - Used for development and testing
+   - Stores all state in memory
+   - No network communication required
+   - Fast and suitable for local development
+
+2. **Remote (Protobuf):**
+   - Used in production environments
+   - Communicates over network using protobuf messages
+   - Supports WebSocket transport
+   - Enables integration with remote services
+
+The Data Layer provides a complete interface for all editor operations, handling both scene state and asset management. It serves as the primary communication channel between the Inspector and its host environment, responsible for:
+
+1. **Scene State Management:**
+
+   - Maintains scene entity hierarchy and component data
+   - Synchronizes state changes through CRDT streaming
+   - Handles undo/redo operations
+   - Manages scene saving and loading
+
+2. **Asset Management:**
+   - Creates and modifies custom items
+   - Manages the asset catalog
+   - Handles asset metadata and thumbnails
+   - Controls asset lifecycle (create, rename, delete)
+
+The Data Layer is implemented as a protobuf-defined RPC service to ensure type safety and versioning:
+
+```protobuf
+service DataService {
+  // Scene state synchronization
+  rpc CrdtStream(stream CrdtStreamMessage) returns (stream CrdtStreamMessage)
+
+  // Asset management
+  rpc CreateCustomAsset(CreateCustomAssetRequest) returns (CreateCustomAssetResponse)
+  rpc GetCustomAssets(Empty) returns (GetCustomAssetsResponse)
+  rpc GetAssetCatalog(Empty) returns (AssetCatalogResponse)
+  rpc DeleteCustomAsset(DeleteCustomAssetRequest) returns (Empty)
+  rpc RenameCustomAsset(RenameCustomAssetRequest) returns (Empty)
+
+  // File operations
+  rpc GetFiles(GetFilesRequest) returns (GetFilesResponse)
+  rpc SaveFile(SaveFileRequest) returns (Empty)
+  rpc GetFile(GetFileRequest) returns (GetFileResponse)
+  rpc CopyFile(CopyFileRequest) returns (Empty)
+
+  // Editor state
+  rpc Undo(Empty) returns (UndoRedoResponse)
+  rpc Redo(Empty) returns (UndoRedoResponse)
+  rpc Save(Empty) returns (Empty)
+}
+```
+
+### File System Interface
+
+The File System Interface is a lower-level abstraction focused solely on file operations. It has three distinct implementations:
+
+1. In-Memory ([`feeded-local-fs.ts`](https://github.com/decentraland/js-sdk-toolchain/tree/main/packages/@dcl/inspector/src/lib/data-layer/client/feeded-local-fs.ts)):
+
+   - Uses Map data structures to store files in memory
+   - Simulates a complete file system
+   - Used for development and testing
+   - No persistence between sessions
+
+2. Node.js ([`sdk-commands/start/data-layer/rpc.ts`](https://github.com/decentraland/js-sdk-toolchain/tree/main/packages/@dcl/sdk-commands/src/commands/start/data-layer/rpc.ts)):
+
+   - Direct implementation using Node.js `fs` module
+   - Used by the CLI for local development
+   - Handles file watching and hot reloading
+   - Provides real filesystem access
+
+3. IFrame ([`iframe-storage.ts`](https://github.com/decentraland/js-sdk-toolchain/tree/main/packages/@dcl/inspector/src/lib/logic/storage/iframe.ts)):
+   - Uses mini-rpc library for communication
+   - Delegates file operations to parent window through postMessage
+   - Parent window implements actual storage:
+     - Web Editor: Uses Builder Server API
+     - Creators Hub: Uses Electron's Node.js `fs` module
+   - Enables browser and desktop support through abstraction
+
+The interface definition remains intentionally simple:
+
+```typescript
+export type FileSystemInterface = {
+  dirname: (path: string) => string;
+  basename: (filePath: string) => string;
+  join: (...paths: string[]) => string;
+  existFile: (filePath: string) => Promise<boolean>;
+  readFile: (filePath: string) => Promise<Buffer>;
+  writeFile: (filePath: string, content: Buffer) => Promise<void>;
+  readdir: (
+    dirPath: string
+  ) => Promise<{ name: string; isDirectory: boolean }[]>;
+  rm: (filePath: string) => Promise<void>;
+  cwd: () => string;
+};
+```
+
+### Additional RPCs
+
+All additional RPCs are implemented using the [`@dcl/mini-rpc`](https://github.com/decentraland/mini-rpc) library, which provides type-safe client/server communication. These include:
+
+1. Storage RPC: Implements the IFrame file system interface
+2. Camera RPC: Controls viewport and screenshots
+3. UI RPC: Manages Inspector UI state
+4. Scene Metrics RPC: Reports scene statistics
+
+Each RPC uses postMessage for transport in IFrame implementations and follows the mini-rpc pattern of:
+
+- Type-safe method definitions
+- Client/server architecture
+- Event emission capabilities
+
+### Relationship Between Layers
+
+The Data Layer uses the File System Interface but adds:
+
+- Scene-specific operations (CRDT streaming, undo/redo)
+- Asset management (custom items, catalogs)
+- Editor state management
+- Higher-level abstractions for scene editing
+
+Example:
+
+- When creating a custom item, the Data Layer:
+  1. Handles the item metadata and composition
+  2. Uses the File System Interface to store resources
+  3. Manages thumbnails and previews
+  4. Updates the asset catalog
+
+While the File System Interface would only handle the raw file operations without understanding the asset structure or scene context.
+
+# Integration Points
+
+## CLI Integration
+
+The primary integration point is through the Decentraland CLI (`@dcl/sdk-commands`):
+
+- Starts a local development server
+- Creates a WebSocket server for the Data Layer
+- Handles file watching and hot reloading
+- Manages the scene's build process
+- Provides the RPC server implementation for the Data Layer
+- Implements a FileSystemInterface on top of NodeJS `fs`
+
+### VSCode Extension
+
+The VSCode extension is a separate product that:
+
+- Uses the CLI as its backend server
+- Launches the CLI's `start` command with the `--data-layer` flag
+- Connects to the CLI's WebSocket server
+- Embeds the Inspector in a VSCode webview
+- Inherits all functionality through the CLI's server implementation
+
+### Web Editor
+
+The Web Editor integration:
+
+- Embeds the Inspector in an IFrame within the web application
+- Uses postMessage for RPC communication between Inspector and parent window
+- Implements the FileSystemInterface server against the Builder Server's API:
+  - File operations are translated to API calls
+  - Assets and resources are stored in the Builder's backend
+  - Handles user authentication and project permissions
+- Provides custom UI controls through the UI RPC
+
+### Creators Hub
+
+The Creators Hub integration:
+
+- Embeds the Inspector in an IFrame within the Electron application
+- Uses postMessage for RPC communication between Inspector and parent window
+- Implements the FileSystemInterface server using Electron's Node.js capabilities:
+  - Direct access to local filesystem through Node.js `fs` module
+  - Local storage of assets and resources
+- Takes screenshots of the scene to generate thumbnails for the projects
+
+# Consequences
+
+## Positive
+
+- Decoupled architecture through RPC interfaces
+- Flexible backend implementations
+- Consistent API across platforms
+- Type-safe communication through protobuf
+
+## Negative
+
+- Complex RPC layer management
+- Multiple transport mechanisms to maintain
+- Potential version mismatches between implementations
+- Performance overhead from RPC communication
+
+# References
+
+- [Decentraland SDK Repository](https://github.com/decentraland/js-sdk-tooling)
+- [Inspector Package](https://github.com/decentraland/js-sdk-toolchain/tree/main/packages/@dcl/inspector)