Fix incorrect keying of by= results involving functions of keys (#6708)

* add test

* Implement a fix

* Another test with multiple keys

* NEWS

* redundant return

* fix numbering

NEWS.md

@@ -131,6 +131,8 @@ rowwiseDT(
 
 18. `as.data.table()` method for `data.frame`s (especially those with extended classes) is more consistent with `as.data.frame()` with respect to rention of attributes, [#5699](https://github.com/Rdatatable/data.table/issues/5699). Thanks @jangorecki for the report and fix.
 
+19. Grouped queries on keyed tables no longer return an incorrectly keyed result if the _ad hoc_ `by=` list has some function call (in particular, a function which happens to return a strictly decreasing function of the keys), e.g. `by=.(a = rev(a))`, [#5583](https://github.com/Rdatatable/data.table/issues/5583). Thanks @AbrJA for the report and @MichaelChirico for the fix.
+
 ## NOTES
 
 1. There is a new vignette on joins! See `vignette("datatable-joins")`. Thanks to Angel Feliz for authoring it! Feedback welcome. This vignette has been highly requested since 2017: [#2181](https://github.com/Rdatatable/data.table/issues/2181).

R/data.table.R

@@ -2014,8 +2014,8 @@ replace_dot_alias = function(e) {
     if (verbose) {last.started.at=proc.time();catf("setkey() afterwards for keyby=.EACHI ... ");flush.console()}
     setkeyv(ans,names(ans)[seq_along(byval)])
     if (verbose) {cat(timetaken(last.started.at),"\n"); flush.console()}
-  } else if (keyby || (haskey(x) && bysameorder && (byjoin || (length(allbyvars) && identical(allbyvars,head(key(x),length(allbyvars))))))) {
-    setattr(ans,"sorted",names(ans)[seq_along(grpcols)])
+  } else if (.by_result_is_keyable(x, keyby, bysameorder, byjoin, allbyvars, bysub)) {
+    setattr(ans, "sorted", names(ans)[seq_along(grpcols)])
   }
   setalloccol(ans)   # TODO: overallocate in dogroups in the first place and remove this line
 }
@@ -3051,6 +3051,21 @@ rleidv = function(x, cols=seq_along(x), prefix=NULL) {
   ids
 }
 
+.by_result_is_keyable = function(x, keyby, bysameorder, byjoin, byvars, bysub) {
+  if (keyby) return(TRUE)
+  k = key(x)
+  if (is.null(k)) return(FALSE) # haskey(x) but saving 'k' for below
+  if (!bysameorder) return(FALSE)
+  if (byjoin) return(TRUE)
+  if (!length(byvars)) return(FALSE)
+  if (!identical(byvars, head(k, length(byvars)))) return(FALSE) # match key exactly, in order
+  # For #5583, we also ensure there are no function calls in by (which might break sortedness)
+  if (is.name(bysub)) return(TRUE)
+  if (identical(bysub[[1L]], quote(list))) bysub = bysub[-1L]
+  if (length(all.names(bysub)) > length(byvars)) return(FALSE)
+  TRUE
+}
+
 .is_withFALSE_range = function(e, x, root=root_name(e), vars=all.vars(e)) {
   if (root != ":") return(FALSE)
   if (!length(vars)) return(TRUE)              # e.g. 1:10

inst/tests/tests.Rraw

@@ -20757,3 +20757,10 @@ as.data.frame.tbl = function(x) {
   x
 }
 test(2302, attr(as.data.table(y), "t1"), attr(as.data.frame(y), "t1"))
+
+# by=foo(KEY) does not retain key (no way to guarantee monotonic transformation), #5583
+DT = data.table(a=1:2, key='a')
+test(2303.1, DT[, .N, by=.(b=rev(a))], data.table(b=2:1, N=1L))
+test(2303.2, DT[, .(N=1L), by=.(b=rev(a))], data.table(b=2:1, N=1L)) # ensure no interaction with GForce
+DT = data.table(a=2:3, b=1:0, key=c('a', 'b'))
+test(2303.3, DT[, .N, by=.(ab=a^b, d=c(1L, 1L))], data.table(ab=c(2, 1), d=1L, N=1L))