App should indicate ingredients are supplied by the producer (and can't be edited)

[alexgarel]

What

Reported on slack: The ingredients list might be supplied by the producer, in which case it is not editable. On nutrition we have a small factory logo for that, but there is no indications for ingredients.

Steps to reproduce the behavior

1. Scan this product https://world.openfoodfacts.org/product/3560070614202/oat-flakes-carrefour
2. Go to modify
3. Ingredients
4. No factory icon indicates that this is supplied by the producer

[monsieurtanuki]

Indeed we should, and we already have the flags for that in https://fr.openfoodfacts.org/api/v3/product/3560070614202?fields=owner_fields:

            "ingredients_text_en": 1721360743,
            "ingredients_text_es": 1721360743,
            "ingredients_text_fr": 1721360743,
            "ingredients_text_it": 1721360743,
            "ingredients_text_nl": 1721360743,
            "ingredients_text_pl": 1721360743,
            "ingredients_text_ro": 1721360743,

I'm glad that users do understand the meaning of the factory logo.

[github-throwaway]

Is this shown in the app as well? I can't seem to find the factory icon 🙈

[monsieurtanuki]

@github-throwaway Don't hesitate to mention the barcode you're using for your screenshots.
The factory logo appears only in the "edit" pages. It's supposed to be there in your last screenshot, assuming that the nutrition facts are provided by the producer.

[github-throwaway]

I used the product mentioned above: https://world.openfoodfacts.org/product/3560070614202/oat-flakes-carrefour

[g123k]

In this issue, it's for ingredients and not for the nutrition facts.
And the owner field is perfectly visible, eg with this product: https://fr.openfoodfacts.org/produit/3564700169643/mini-cakes-aux-fruits-p-tit-deli

[github-throwaway]

Yup. I got that part. I was just curious what the factory icon looks like. Because I don't see it. Or am I blind?😅

[g123k]

The idea behind this issue is to add it to the app 🙃
You can't find it now.

[github-throwaway]

Ah. I thought "On nutrition we have a small factory logo for that, but there is no indications for ingredients." means that it is already implement for the nutrition page. My bad. Sorry about the confusion 😄

[monsieurtanuki]

@github-throwaway There is a factory logo in those pages.

The problem may be:

• you use an old version of the app, without that factory logo being added
• we recently had issues with logo colors, which may be the same color as the background

example 1	example 2

[github-throwaway]

Ahhh. Then it's probably the version. How can I get the lastest version of there is no update available in the App Store? 😅

Also if the manufacturer provides the data wouldn't it be better to not show the option to edit at all? Cause the option to even get to that screen would lead the user to believe it would be possible to edit and then they realise they can't? What if the factory icon is displayed in the ingredients display dialogue instead?

Maybe even put a report a problem button below the ingredients? 🤔

[monsieurtanuki]

Ahhh. Then it's probably the version. How can I get the lastest version of there is no update available in the App Store? 😅

Probably blocked by #6006

Also if the manufacturer provides the data wouldn't it be better to not show the option to edit at all? Cause the option to even get to that screen would lead the user to believe it would be possible to edit and then they realise they can't? What if the factory icon is displayed in the ingredients display dialogue instead?

Providing an access to the edit ingredients page may be helpful, if you want to copy the text or see the picture.
I don't know which would be better: hide the ingredients and break the consistency with other products, or put the factory logo.

Maybe even put a report a problem button below the ingredients? 🤔

Would make sense.

For the record we have limited control over the read-only page about ingredients, which is a "knowledge panel" provided by the server.

@github-throwaway Generally speaking, some of your questions go beyond the OP, which was about consistently displaying a factory logo for the edit ingredients page.
You should probably create specific issues for specific needs/questions.

[g123k]

The icon will be visible in an upcoming PR:

[github-throwaway]

@g123k looks great! 😊