Feature: Allow double interactions

[ShootToKillSTK]

Enable the use of things like 'shift + e' 'alt + b' etc.

Normally that will work, but if you also use e for something, and just press e, it will do both of them );

Or is this a thing of this mod? Sorry if so but it doesn't say so, feel like it would if so

• I see only mods for lower versions or there is a only fabric one I believe wit this, for 1.16.4/5 only
• They allow porting to forge

There link: https://www.curseforge.com/minecraft/mc-mods/amecs
Would be an amazing feature for all modpack makers on forge version, like myself!

[jaredlll08]

I'm so confused by this issue.

Controlling just changes the screen, not how keybinds function / are triggered.

I'm also not sure what you mean by:

Or is this a thing of this mod? Sorry if so but it doesn't say so, feel like it would if so

• I see only mods for lower versions or there is a only fabric one I believe wit this, for 1.16.4/5 only
• They allow porting to forge

but Controlling is a Forge mod. There is Controlling for Fabric however.

[egeesin]

I think I have the similar issue.

Assuming we're discussing about Fabric version of Controlling mod since you merged the project, I think what he/she meant is, with Amecs mod you're able to create keybinds like specific combos/keystrokes/macros etc. where you can't in vanilla.
But if you use Amecs and Controlling together, you aren't able to create new keybindings like Left Control+S, Shift+Control etc. If you try to do that, it only binds the first modifier key (Control, Shift). The only bright side is Controlling doesn't meddle with existing key combos unless you try to edit.

As far as I tested, only workaround is to disabling Controlling temporarily, making keybinds with Amecs enabled on (like Ctrl+?, Shift+?) then enabling Controlling back.

I love the both mods with the things that provides the player much more power to control and giving useful info about it and I hope there will be compatibility between the mods.

P.S. You can change the title as "Unable to make key combos with Amecs." for helping the people who have similar specific issue.

[jaredlll08]

Assuming we're discussing about Fabric version of Controlling mod since you merged the project

At the time that this issue was made, this repository was only for Forge. This has changed since then.

So I'm open adding support for it if Ameks is installed, but I'm not exactly sure about how to go about doing that.

@Siphalor any chance you would be open to discussing how we can glue the mods together?

Alternatively I could just make it that if you hold shift while opening the keybinds screen it opens the vanilla one, which should work, but would not be ideal.

[AlisterGontineac]

You can still add multi-key modifiers with an earlier version on fabric "Controlling-For-Fabric-1.2.0.jar" { https://www.curseforge.com/minecraft/mc-mods/controlling-for-fabric/files/3331405 )

[ajaxnotmeta]

why this also hapens on NeoForge 1.20.1?

[jaredlll08]

Check if you can reproduce without controlling, it is very possible that neoforge itself is broken, I had to make a PR to fix it on 1.21, but I don't know what version it actually broke on.

[ajaxnotmeta]

Check if you can reproduce without controlling, it is very possible that neoforge itself is broken, I had to make a PR to fix it on 1.21, but I don't know what version it actually broke on.

1.21 seems fine, but 1.20.1 both neoforge and lexforge suffers the same bugs

[jaredlll08]

I just tested using Forge on it's own, and with Controlling and I cannot reproduce any bugs with setting double interactions on 1.20.1.

I also tested with Neoforge on it's own (no Controlling version for 1.20.1 neoforge), and also can't reproduce any bug.

If you are experiencing a bug, make sure you are on the latest version of everything.

[NicKnack819]

May Be late and possibly wrong but if I remember correctly the overlapping key binds making it so the game does not allow other bound functions to trigger was one of the 1.20.1 bugs that got patched after the next few updates so the work around I found that works best is using Modern Keybinding as it allows you to set key binds that still work even if they conflict with some logic I don't understand but know usually works to fix the issue.

NonConflictKeys For Forge
Modern Keybinding For Fabric

[NicKnack819]

Just wanna ask were you wanting to use key bind fix? If so that is the cause it allows keys to be double bound but it keeps the original bind unless changed in the files I've seen which sucks