Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

derivation: rocket equation #18

Open
bhpayne opened this issue Jan 26, 2025 · 6 comments
Open

derivation: rocket equation #18

bhpayne opened this issue Jan 26, 2025 · 6 comments
Assignees

Comments

@bhpayne
Copy link
Member Author

bhpayne commented Jan 26, 2025

prompt to Gemini 2.0 Flash Thinking Experimental 01-21 https://aistudio.google.com/prompts/

In mathematical Physics a derivation is comprised of steps and expressions. An expression is comprised of symbols and operators.

Derive the rocket equation from first principles. Describe each step in detail, and explain the process of getting from one step to the next.

Format the output as a single Latex document.

thoughts

Here's a breakdown of the thinking process to construct the LaTeX derivation of the rocket equation:

  1. Understand the Request: The request is to derive the rocket equation from first principles. This means starting with fundamental physical laws, specifically Newton's second law and the principle of conservation of momentum (or equivalently, considering momentum change). The request also emphasizes detailed steps, explanations, and formatting as a LaTeX document.

  2. Identify First Principles: The core principle is the conservation of momentum. We need to consider the system's momentum before and after a small amount of fuel is expelled. Newton's second law (F=ma) is also implicitly involved in relating force to momentum change.

  3. Define the System: The system is the rocket plus the exhaust gases being ejected. It's crucial to include the exhaust gases as part of the system because we are dealing with momentum conservation. If we only consider the rocket, momentum isn't conserved because mass is leaving the rocket.

  4. Choose a Time Interval: To analyze the change in momentum, we need to consider a small time interval, dt. This allows us to use differentials and eventually integrate.

  5. Define Variables: Clearly define all variables used. This is essential for clarity in a physics derivation. The key variables are:

    • M(t): Mass of the rocket at time t (including unspent fuel).
    • v(t): Velocity of the rocket at time t (in an inertial frame).
    • v_e: Exhaust velocity relative to the rocket (assumed constant and negative since it's in the opposite direction of rocket motion).
    • dm: Mass of fuel ejected during dt. Note that dm is a positive quantity representing the magnitude of mass ejected. The change in rocket mass is dM = -dm.
    • dv: Change in rocket velocity during dt.
  6. Momentum Before Ejection (at time t):

    • The momentum of the system before ejection is simply the momentum of the rocket: P(t) = M(t)v(t).
  7. Momentum After Ejection (at time t + dt): This is the crucial step. We need to consider the momentum of both the rocket and the expelled fuel.

    • Rocket Momentum: The rocket's mass has decreased to M(t) + dM = M(t) - dm, and its velocity has increased to v(t) + dv. So, the rocket's momentum is (M(t) - dm)(v(t) + dv).
    • Exhaust Momentum: We need the velocity of the exhaust relative to the inertial frame. The exhaust velocity relative to the rocket is v_e. Since the rocket's velocity is v(t), the exhaust velocity relative to the inertial frame is v(t) + v_e. The mass of the exhaust is dm. So, the exhaust momentum is dm(v(t) + v_e).
    • Total Momentum After Ejection: Sum the rocket momentum and exhaust momentum: P(t + dt) = (M(t) - dm)(v(t) + dv) + dm(v(t) + v_e).
  8. Apply Conservation of Momentum: In the absence of external forces (this is a key assumption for the basic rocket equation), momentum is conserved. Therefore, P(t) = P(t + dt).

  9. Expand and Simplify: Set P(t) = P(t + dt) and expand the equation:
    M(t)v(t) = (M(t) - dm)(v(t) + dv) + dm(v(t) + v_e)
    Expand the product: M(t)v(t) = M(t)v(t) + M(t)dv - dm v(t) - dm dv + dm v(t) + dm v_e
    Cancel M(t)v(t) on both sides and cancel -dm v(t) and +dm v(t):
    0 = M(t)dv - dm dv + dm v_e

  10. Neglect Higher Order Terms: The term dm dv is a product of two infinitesimals and is considered negligible compared to the other terms in the limit as dt approaches zero. Therefore, we drop dm dv.

  11. Rearrange and Separate Variables: We are left with: 0 = M(t)dv + dm v_e Rearrange to isolate dv:
    M(t)dv = -dm v_e
    dv = -v_e \frac{dm}{M(t)}

  12. Relate dm and dM: Recall that dM = -dm. So, dm = -dM. Substitute this into the equation:
    dv = -v_e \frac{-dM}{M(t)} = v_e \frac{dM}{M(t)}

  13. Integrate: To find the change in velocity over a finite burn time, we need to integrate both sides. Assume v_e is constant.
    ∫ dv = ∫ v_e \frac{dM}{M}
    Integrate from initial velocity v_0 (at initial mass M_0) to final velocity v_f (at final mass M_f):
    ∫_{v_0}^{v_f} dv = v_e ∫_{M_0}^{M_f} \frac{dM}{M}
    [v]_{v_0}^{v_f} = v_e [\ln|M|]_{M_0}^{M_f}
    v_f - v_0 = v_e (\ln(M_f) - \ln(M_0))

  14. Simplify using Logarithm Properties: Use the property ln(a) - ln(b) = ln(a/b):
    Δv = v_f - v_0 = v_e \ln\left(\frac{M_f}{M_0}\right)

  15. Express in terms of Initial and Final Mass Ratio: It's more common to express the equation in terms of the initial mass M_i and final mass M_f where M_i > M_f. To get a positive Δv (assuming v_e is positive magnitude and we are considering the magnitude of the exhaust velocity), we should have the logarithm of a ratio greater than 1. So, rewrite as:
    Δv = v_e \ln\left(\frac{M_0}{M_f}\right) (Using M_0 as initial mass, M_f as final mass).
    Or, if we use M_i for initial and M_f for final:
    Δv = v_e \ln\left(\frac{M_i}{M_f}\right)

  16. Consider Exhaust Velocity Sign: If we define v_e as the exhaust velocity relative to the rocket and it's in the opposite direction of motion, then v_e is negative. In that case, the original dv = -v_e \frac{dm}{M} is correct, and if v_e is negative, then Δv will be positive, which is physically correct. Often, v_e is taken as the magnitude of the exhaust velocity, in which case we write Δv = |v_e| \ln(M_i/M_f). For simplicity in this derivation, keep v_e as the exhaust velocity relative to the rocket, and let it be negative if in the opposite direction of motion. Then Δv = -v_e \ln(M_f/M_i) = v_e \ln(M_i/M_f) if we assume v_e is the magnitude and positive, and put the negative sign explicitly to indicate direction in the momentum equations if needed. Let's stick with v_e as a positive magnitude, and use the negative sign in dv = -v_e dm/M to indicate the direction.

  17. Final Equation and Interpretation: The rocket equation is Δv = v_e \ln\left(\frac{M_i}{M_f}\right). Explain what each term represents and the implications:

    • Δv: Change in velocity (delta-v).
    • v_e: Exhaust velocity (magnitude).
    • M_i: Initial mass (including fuel).
    • M_f: Final mass (after fuel burn).
    • The equation shows that Δv increases with exhaust velocity and the ratio of initial to final mass.
  18. LaTeX Formatting: Structure the derivation using LaTeX. Use \documentclass{article}, \usepackage{amsmath}, \usepackage{amsfonts}, \usepackage{amssymb} for math symbols and environments. Use \section, \subsection, \textbf, \textit, \begin{equation}, \end{equation}, \begin{itemize}, \item, etc. for structure and formatting. Use align* environment for multi-line equations with alignment. Ensure clear and concise explanations for each step.

  19. Review and Refine: Read through the derivation to ensure logical flow, clarity, and correctness. Check variable definitions, steps, and explanations. Make sure the LaTeX compiles correctly and looks well-formatted. Double-check signs and directions. Ensure the explanation is detailed as requested.

By following these steps, we can construct a well-structured and detailed LaTeX derivation of the rocket equation from first principles.

response

\documentclass{article}
\usepackage{amsmath}
\usepackage{amsfonts}
\usepackage{amssymb}

\title{Derivation of the Rocket Equation from First Principles}
\date{\today}

\begin{document}
\maketitle

\section{Introduction}

The rocket equation, also known as the Tsiolkovsky rocket equation, is a fundamental relationship in astronautics that describes the change in velocity ($\Delta v$) a rocket can achieve based on its exhaust velocity and the ratio of its initial and final mass. This derivation starts from first principles, specifically Newton's second law and the conservation of momentum, to arrive at this crucial equation. We will meticulously detail each step and the reasoning behind it.

\section{Step 1: Define the System and Initial Conditions}

Consider a rocket in free space, far from any gravitational fields or atmospheric drag. This simplifies our analysis by eliminating external forces. We define our system as the rocket \textit{and} the exhaust gases expelled from it. This is crucial for applying the principle of conservation of momentum, as momentum is conserved for a closed system.

At an initial time $t$, let's define the following quantities:
\begin{itemize}
    \item $M(t)$: The mass of the rocket at time $t$. This includes the mass of the rocket structure and the remaining fuel.
    \item $v(t)$: The velocity of the rocket at time $t$ with respect to an inertial reference frame. We will consider motion in one dimension for simplicity, and treat velocity as a scalar.
\end{itemize}
The initial momentum of the system at time $t$, $P(t)$, is simply the momentum of the rocket, as the exhaust gases are initially part of the rocket and moving with it.
\begin{equation}
    P(t) = M(t) v(t)
    \label{eq:1}
\end{equation}

\section{Step 2: Consider a Small Time Interval $\Delta t$}

Now, consider a small time interval $\Delta t$. During this interval, the rocket expels a small amount of fuel as exhaust gases. We define the following changes and quantities during this interval:
\begin{itemize}
    \item $\Delta m$: The mass of fuel expelled as exhaust gases during the time interval $\Delta t$. Note that $\Delta m$ is a positive quantity.
    \item $\Delta v$: The change in the rocket's velocity during the time interval $\Delta t$. The new velocity of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$ will be $v(t + \Delta t) = v(t) + \Delta v$.
    \item $v_e$: The exhaust velocity of the expelled gases \textit{relative to the rocket}. We assume this exhaust velocity is constant throughout the burn for simplicity.  If the exhaust is directed opposite to the rocket's motion, $v_e$ will be negative in our chosen coordinate system (where the positive direction is the direction of the rocket's velocity). However, for the derivation, we will consider $v_e$ as the magnitude of the exhaust velocity and explicitly consider its direction in our momentum calculations. Let's consider $v_e$ to be directed opposite to the rocket's velocity, so it will be negative.
\end{itemize}

\section{Step 3: Calculate the Momentum at Time $t + \Delta t$}

At time $t + \Delta t$, we have two components to consider for the momentum of our system: the rocket itself (now with reduced mass and changed velocity) and the expelled exhaust gases.

\subsection{Momentum of the Rocket at $t + \Delta t$}
The mass of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$ is $M(t + \Delta t) = M(t) - \Delta m$. The velocity of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$ is $v(t + \Delta t) = v(t) + \Delta v$. Therefore, the momentum of the rocket at $t + \Delta t$ is:
\begin{equation}
    P_{\text{rocket}}(t + \Delta t) = (M(t) - \Delta m)(v(t) + \Delta v)
    \label{eq:2}
\end{equation}

\subsection{Momentum of the Exhaust Gases at $t + \Delta t$}
We need to find the velocity of the exhaust gases with respect to our inertial reference frame. The exhaust velocity $v_e$ is given relative to the rocket.  Since the rocket's velocity at time $t$ is $v(t)$, and the exhaust is directed opposite to the rocket's motion (in the rocket's frame), the velocity of the exhaust gases in the inertial frame is $v(t) + v_e$.  Since $v_e$ is negative (opposite to the rocket's velocity), this effectively means the exhaust gas velocity in the inertial frame is $v(t) - |v_e|$ if we consider $|v_e|$ as the magnitude of exhaust velocity.  However, keeping $v_e$ as negative exhaust velocity relative to the rocket in the direction of the rocket's motion simplifies the notation. So, the velocity of the exhaust gases in the inertial frame is $v(t) + v_e$. The mass of the exhaust gases is $\Delta m$. Therefore, the momentum of the exhaust gases at $t + \Delta t$ is:
\begin{equation}
    P_{\text{exhaust}}(t + \Delta t) = \Delta m (v(t) + v_e)
    \label{eq:3}
\end{equation}

\subsection{Total Momentum at $t + \Delta t$}
The total momentum of the system at time $t + \Delta t$ is the sum of the momentum of the rocket and the momentum of the exhaust gases:
\begin{equation}
    P(t + \Delta t) = P_{\text{rocket}}(t + \Delta t) + P_{\text{exhaust}}(t + \Delta t) = (M(t) - \Delta m)(v(t) + \Delta v) + \Delta m (v(t) + v_e)
    \label{eq:4}
\end{equation}

\section{Step 4: Apply Conservation of Momentum}

Since we are considering a closed system in free space with no external forces, the total momentum of the system must be conserved. Therefore, the momentum at time $t$ must be equal to the momentum at time $t + \Delta t$:
\begin{equation}
    P(t) = P(t + \Delta t)
    \label{eq:5}
\end{equation}
Substituting equations \eqref{eq:1} and \eqref{eq:4} into equation \eqref{eq:5}:
\begin{equation}
    M(t) v(t) = (M(t) - \Delta m)(v(t) + \Delta v) + \Delta m (v(t) + v_e)
    \label{eq:6}
\end{equation}

\section{Step 5: Simplify and Rearrange the Equation}

Expand the right side of equation \eqref{eq:6}:
\begin{align*}
    M(t) v(t) &= M(t)v(t) + M(t)\Delta v - \Delta m v(t) - \Delta m \Delta v + \Delta m v(t) + \Delta m v_e \\
    M(t) v(t) &= M(t)v(t) + M(t)\Delta v - \Delta m \Delta v + \Delta m v_e
\end{align*}
Subtract $M(t)v(t)$ from both sides:
\begin{equation}
    0 = M(t)\Delta v - \Delta m \Delta v + \Delta m v_e
    \label{eq:7}
\end{equation}
We now consider the limit as $\Delta t \rightarrow 0$. In this limit, $\Delta m$ and $\Delta v$ become infinitesimally small, denoted by $dm$ and $dv$ respectively. The term $\Delta m \Delta v$ becomes a second-order infinitesimal and can be neglected compared to the first-order terms $M(t)\Delta v$ and $\Delta m v_e$.  Thus, in the limit, equation \eqref{eq:7} becomes:
\begin{equation}
    0 = M(t)dv + dm v_e
    \label{eq:8}
\end{equation}
Rearranging equation \eqref{eq:8} to solve for $dv$:
\begin{equation}
    M(t)dv = -v_e dm
    \label{eq:9}
\end{equation}
\begin{equation}
    dv = -v_e \frac{dm}{M(t)}
    \label{eq:10}
\end{equation}
Since $dm$ is the mass of fuel expelled, it represents a decrease in the rocket's mass. Therefore, the change in the rocket's mass, $dM$, is negative and equal to $-dm$, i.e., $dM = -dm$. Substituting $dm = -dM$ into equation \eqref{eq:10}:
\begin{equation}
    dv = -v_e \frac{-dM}{M(t)} = v_e \frac{dM}{M(t)}
    \label{eq:11}
\end{equation}
Note that if we take $v_e$ as the magnitude of the exhaust velocity (a positive value), and we consider the exhaust to be in the opposite direction of the rocket's motion, then the direction is accounted for by the negative sign in equation \eqref{eq:9}, making $dv$ positive when $dM$ is negative (mass decreases, velocity increases).  However, if we consider $v_e$ to be negative as initially defined (velocity relative to the rocket in the direction of rocket motion, and exhaust is in the opposite direction, so $v_e < 0$), then equation \eqref{eq:10} and \eqref{eq:11} still hold, and $dv$ will be positive for negative $v_e$ and negative $dM$. For clarity, let's assume $v_e$ is the magnitude of the exhaust velocity, so $v_e > 0$. Then we need to consider the direction explicitly. If the exhaust is in the opposite direction of the rocket's motion, we should write equation \eqref{eq:9} as $Mdv = v_e (-dm)$, where $v_e$ is now the magnitude, and $(-dm)$ is the mass expelled in the direction opposite to the rocket motion in the rocket frame.  Then $dv = -v_e \frac{dm}{M}$ (using $dm$ as positive mass expelled), and since $dM = -dm$, we get $dv = v_e \frac{dM}{M}$.

\section{Step 6: Integrate to Find the Total Velocity Change}

To find the total change in velocity $\Delta v$ as the rocket mass changes from an initial mass $M_i$ to a final mass $M_f$, we integrate equation \eqref{eq:11}:
\begin{equation}
    \int_{v_i}^{v_f} dv = \int_{M_i}^{M_f} v_e \frac{dM}{M}
    \label{eq:12}
\end{equation}
Assuming the exhaust velocity $v_e$ is constant during the burn, we can take it out of the integral:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = v_f - v_i = v_e \int_{M_i}^{M_f} \frac{dM}{M}
    \label{eq:13}
\end{equation}
The integral of $\frac{1}{M} dM$ is $\ln|M|$. Evaluating the definite integral:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = v_e [\ln|M|]_{M_i}^{M_f} = v_e (\ln|M_f| - \ln|M_i|)
    \label{eq:14}
\end{equation}
Using the property of logarithms $\ln(a) - \ln(b) = \ln\left(\frac{a}{b}\right)$:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = v_e \ln\left(\frac{M_f}{M_i}\right)
    \label{eq:15}
\end{equation}
Since $M_i > M_f$ (the final mass is less than the initial mass after expelling fuel), the ratio $\frac{M_f}{M_i} < 1$, and $\ln\left(\frac{M_f}{M_i}\right)$ will be negative. To have a positive $\Delta v$ (increase in speed in the direction of intended motion if $v_e$ is magnitude), we should write it as:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = -v_e \ln\left(\frac{M_f}{M_i}\right) = v_e \ln\left(\frac{M_i}{M_f}\right)
    \label{eq:16}
\end{equation}
Here, $v_e$ is the magnitude of the exhaust velocity, and $\Delta v$ is the magnitude of the change in rocket velocity.  $\frac{M_i}{M_f}$ is the mass ratio, which is always greater than 1 for a rocket burn, so $\ln\left(\frac{M_i}{M_f}\right) > 0$, and thus $\Delta v > 0$.

\section{Step 7: The Rocket Equation}

Equation \eqref{eq:16} is the rocket equation. It expresses the change in velocity $\Delta v$ of a rocket as a function of the exhaust velocity $v_e$ and the ratio of the initial mass $M_i$ to the final mass $M_f$.

\textbf{Rocket Equation:}
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = v_e \ln\left(\frac{M_i}{M_f}\right)
    \label{eq:17}
\end{equation}

\section{Conclusion}

We have derived the rocket equation from first principles, starting with the conservation of momentum and considering a small mass of fuel being expelled over a small time interval. By considering the momentum of both the rocket and the exhaust gases before and after the expulsion, and then integrating the resulting differential equation, we arrived at the rocket equation. This equation highlights the key factors influencing a rocket's velocity change: the exhaust velocity and the mass ratio. A higher exhaust velocity and a larger mass ratio (meaning a larger proportion of initial mass is fuel) result in a greater achievable change in velocity. This equation is fundamental for space mission planning and rocket design.

\end{document}

@bhpayne
Copy link
Member Author

bhpayne commented Jan 26, 2025

prompt to Gemini 2.0 Flash Thinking Experimental 01-21 https://aistudio.google.com/prompts/

The following latex file contains equations and variables. Provide a list, formatted as Latex, of every unique variable and a description of that variable.

For each entry in the list include a reference to the labeled equations where each variable is used. Write out just the Latex list as your answer.

\documentclass{article}
\usepackage{amsmath}
%\usepackage{amsfonts}
%\usepackage{amssymb}

% margins of 1 inch:
\setlength{\topmargin}{-.5in}
\setlength{\textheight}{9in}
\setlength{\oddsidemargin}{0in}
\setlength{\textwidth}{6.5in}

\usepackage[pdftex]{hyperref} % hyperlink equation and bibliographic citations

\title{Derivation of the Rocket Equation from First Principles}
\author{Ben Payne, with Gemini 2.0}
\date{\today}

\begin{document}
\maketitle

\section{Introduction}

The rocket equation, also known as the Tsiolkovsky rocket equation, is a fundamental relationship in astronautics that describes the change in velocity ($\Delta v$) a rocket can achieve based on its exhaust velocity and the ratio of its initial and final mass. This derivation starts from first principles, specifically Newton's second law and the conservation of momentum, to arrive at this crucial equation. We will meticulously detail each step and the reasoning behind it.

\section{Step 1: Define the System and Initial Conditions}

Consider a rocket in free space, far from any gravitational fields or atmospheric drag. This simplifies our analysis by eliminating external forces. We define our system as the rocket \textit{and} the exhaust gases expelled from it. This is crucial for applying the principle of conservation of momentum, as momentum is conserved for a closed system.

At an initial time $t$, let's define the following quantities:
\begin{itemize}
    \item $M(t)$: The mass of the rocket at time $t$. This includes the mass of the rocket structure and the remaining fuel.
    \item $v(t)$: The velocity of the rocket at time $t$ with respect to an inertial reference frame. We will consider motion in one dimension for simplicity, and treat velocity as a scalar.
\end{itemize}
The initial momentum of the system at time $t$, $P(t)$, is simply the momentum of the rocket, as the exhaust gases are initially part of the rocket and moving with it.
\begin{equation}
    P(t) = M(t) v(t)
    \label{eq:1}
\end{equation}

\section{Step 2: Consider a Small Time Interval $\Delta t$}

Now, consider a small time interval $\Delta t$. During this interval, the rocket expels a small amount of fuel as exhaust gases. We define the following changes and quantities during this interval:
\begin{itemize}
    \item $\Delta m$: The mass of fuel expelled as exhaust gases during the time interval $\Delta t$. Note that $\Delta m$ is a positive quantity.
    \item $\Delta v$: The change in the rocket's velocity during the time interval $\Delta t$. The new velocity of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$ will be $v(t + \Delta t) = v(t) + \Delta v$.
    \item $v_e$: The exhaust velocity of the expelled gases \textit{relative to the rocket}. We assume this exhaust velocity is constant throughout the burn for simplicity.  If the exhaust is directed opposite to the rocket's motion, $v_e$ will be negative in our chosen coordinate system (where the positive direction is the direction of the rocket's velocity). However, for the derivation, we will consider $v_e$ as the magnitude of the exhaust velocity and explicitly consider its direction in our momentum calculations. Let's consider $v_e$ to be directed opposite to the rocket's velocity, so it will be negative.
\end{itemize}

\section{Step 3: Calculate the Momentum at Time $t + \Delta t$}

At time $t + \Delta t$, we have two components to consider for the momentum of our system: the rocket itself (now with reduced mass and changed velocity) and the expelled exhaust gases.

\subsection{Momentum of the Rocket at $t + \Delta t$}
The mass of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$ is $M(t + \Delta t) = M(t) - \Delta m$. The velocity of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$ is $v(t + \Delta t) = v(t) + \Delta v$. Therefore, the momentum of the rocket at $t + \Delta t$ is:
\begin{equation}
    P_{\text{rocket}}(t + \Delta t) = (M(t) - \Delta m)(v(t) + \Delta v)
    \label{eq:2}
\end{equation}

\subsection{Momentum of the Exhaust Gases at $t + \Delta t$}
We need to find the velocity of the exhaust gases with respect to our inertial reference frame. The exhaust velocity $v_e$ is given relative to the rocket.  Since the rocket's velocity at time $t$ is $v(t)$, and the exhaust is directed opposite to the rocket's motion (in the rocket's frame), the velocity of the exhaust gases in the inertial frame is $v(t) + v_e$.  Since $v_e$ is negative (opposite to the rocket's velocity), this effectively means the exhaust gas velocity in the inertial frame is $v(t) - |v_e|$ if we consider $|v_e|$ as the magnitude of exhaust velocity.  However, keeping $v_e$ as negative exhaust velocity relative to the rocket in the direction of the rocket's motion simplifies the notation. So, the velocity of the exhaust gases in the inertial frame is $v(t) + v_e$. The mass of the exhaust gases is $\Delta m$. Therefore, the momentum of the exhaust gases at $t + \Delta t$ is:
\begin{equation}
    P_{\text{exhaust}}(t + \Delta t) = \Delta m (v(t) + v_e)
    \label{eq:3}
\end{equation}

\subsection{Total Momentum at $t + \Delta t$}
The total momentum of the system at time $t + \Delta t$ is the sum of the momentum of the rocket and the momentum of the exhaust gases:
\begin{equation}
    P(t + \Delta t) = P_{\text{rocket}}(t + \Delta t) + P_{\text{exhaust}}(t + \Delta t) = (M(t) - \Delta m)(v(t) + \Delta v) + \Delta m (v(t) + v_e)
    \label{eq:4}
\end{equation}

\section{Step 4: Apply Conservation of Momentum}

Since we are considering a closed system in free space with no external forces, the total momentum of the system must be conserved. Therefore, the momentum at time $t$ must be equal to the momentum at time $t + \Delta t$:
\begin{equation}
    P(t) = P(t + \Delta t)
    \label{eq:5}
\end{equation}
Substituting equations \eqref{eq:1} and \eqref{eq:4} into equation \eqref{eq:5}:
\begin{equation}
    M(t) v(t) = (M(t) - \Delta m)(v(t) + \Delta v) + \Delta m (v(t) + v_e)
    \label{eq:6}
\end{equation}

\section{Step 5: Simplify and Rearrange the Equation}

Expand the right side of equation \eqref{eq:6}:
\begin{align*}
    M(t) v(t) &= M(t)v(t) + M(t)\Delta v - \Delta m v(t) - \Delta m \Delta v + \Delta m v(t) + \Delta m v_e \\
    M(t) v(t) &= M(t)v(t) + M(t)\Delta v - \Delta m \Delta v + \Delta m v_e
\end{align*}
Subtract $M(t)v(t)$ from both sides:
\begin{equation}
    0 = M(t)\Delta v - \Delta m \Delta v + \Delta m v_e
    \label{eq:7}
\end{equation}
We now consider the limit as $\Delta t \rightarrow 0$. In this limit, $\Delta m$ and $\Delta v$ become infinitesimally small, denoted by $dm$ and $dv$ respectively. The term $\Delta m \Delta v$ becomes a second-order infinitesimal and can be neglected compared to the first-order terms $M(t)\Delta v$ and $\Delta m v_e$.  Thus, in the limit, equation \eqref{eq:7} becomes:
\begin{equation}
    0 = M(t)dv + dm v_e
    \label{eq:8}
\end{equation}
Rearranging equation \eqref{eq:8} to solve for $dv$:
\begin{equation}
    M(t)dv = -v_e dm
    \label{eq:9}
\end{equation}
\begin{equation}
    dv = -v_e \frac{dm}{M(t)}
    \label{eq:10}
\end{equation}
Since $dm$ is the mass of fuel expelled, it represents a decrease in the rocket's mass. Therefore, the change in the rocket's mass, $dM$, is negative and equal to $-dm$, i.e., $dM = -dm$. Substituting $dm = -dM$ into equation \eqref{eq:10}:
\begin{equation}
    dv = -v_e \frac{-dM}{M(t)} = v_e \frac{dM}{M(t)}
    \label{eq:11}
\end{equation}
Note that if we take $v_e$ as the magnitude of the exhaust velocity (a positive value), and we consider the exhaust to be in the opposite direction of the rocket's motion, then the direction is accounted for by the negative sign in equation \eqref{eq:9}, making $dv$ positive when $dM$ is negative (mass decreases, velocity increases).  However, if we consider $v_e$ to be negative as initially defined (velocity relative to the rocket in the direction of rocket motion, and exhaust is in the opposite direction, so $v_e < 0$), then equation \eqref{eq:10} and \eqref{eq:11} still hold, and $dv$ will be positive for negative $v_e$ and negative $dM$. For clarity, let's assume $v_e$ is the magnitude of the exhaust velocity, so $v_e > 0$. Then we need to consider the direction explicitly. If the exhaust is in the opposite direction of the rocket's motion, we should write equation \eqref{eq:9} as $Mdv = v_e (-dm)$, where $v_e$ is now the magnitude, and $(-dm)$ is the mass expelled in the direction opposite to the rocket motion in the rocket frame.  Then $dv = -v_e \frac{dm}{M}$ (using $dm$ as positive mass expelled), and since $dM = -dm$, we get $dv = v_e \frac{dM}{M}$.

\section{Step 6: Integrate to Find the Total Velocity Change}

To find the total change in velocity $\Delta v$ as the rocket mass changes from an initial mass $M_i$ to a final mass $M_f$, we integrate equation \eqref{eq:11}:
\begin{equation}
    \int_{v_i}^{v_f} dv = \int_{M_i}^{M_f} v_e \frac{dM}{M}
    \label{eq:12}
\end{equation}
Assuming the exhaust velocity $v_e$ is constant during the burn, we can take it out of the integral:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = v_f - v_i = v_e \int_{M_i}^{M_f} \frac{dM}{M}
    \label{eq:13}
\end{equation}
The integral of $\frac{1}{M} dM$ is $\ln|M|$. Evaluating the definite integral:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = v_e [\ln|M|]_{M_i}^{M_f} = v_e (\ln|M_f| - \ln|M_i|)
    \label{eq:14}
\end{equation}
Using the property of logarithms $\ln(a) - \ln(b) = \ln\left(\frac{a}{b}\right)$:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = v_e \ln\left(\frac{M_f}{M_i}\right)
    \label{eq:15}
\end{equation}
Since $M_i > M_f$ (the final mass is less than the initial mass after expelling fuel), the ratio $\frac{M_f}{M_i} < 1$, and $\ln\left(\frac{M_f}{M_i}\right)$ will be negative. To have a positive $\Delta v$ (increase in speed in the direction of intended motion if $v_e$ is magnitude), we should write it as:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = -v_e \ln\left(\frac{M_f}{M_i}\right) = v_e \ln\left(\frac{M_i}{M_f}\right)
    \label{eq:16}
\end{equation}
Here, $v_e$ is the magnitude of the exhaust velocity, and $\Delta v$ is the magnitude of the change in rocket velocity.  $\frac{M_i}{M_f}$ is the mass ratio, which is always greater than 1 for a rocket burn, so $\ln\left(\frac{M_i}{M_f}\right) > 0$, and thus $\Delta v > 0$.

\section{Step 7: The Rocket Equation}

Equation \eqref{eq:16} is the rocket equation. It expresses the change in velocity $\Delta v$ of a rocket as a function of the exhaust velocity $v_e$ and the ratio of the initial mass $M_i$ to the final mass $M_f$.

\textbf{Rocket Equation:}
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = v_e \ln\left(\frac{M_i}{M_f}\right)
    \label{eq:17}
\end{equation}

\section{Conclusion}

We have derived the rocket equation from first principles, starting with the conservation of momentum and considering a small mass of fuel being expelled over a small time interval. By considering the momentum of both the rocket and the exhaust gases before and after the expulsion, and then integrating the resulting differential equation, we arrived at the rocket equation. This equation highlights the key factors influencing a rocket's velocity change: the exhaust velocity and the mass ratio. A higher exhaust velocity and a larger mass ratio (meaning a larger proportion of initial mass is fuel) result in a greater achievable change in velocity. This equation is fundamental for space mission planning and rocket design.

\end{document}

thoughts

The user wants a Latex formatted list of variables and their descriptions, along with the equation labels where they are used, based on the provided Latex document.

I need to:

  1. Identify every unique variable in the Latex document.
  2. Write a description for each variable.
  3. Find all the labeled equations where each variable is used.
  4. Format the output as a Latex list, with each item containing the variable, description, and equation references.

Let's go through the document and identify the variables and their uses.

Variables:

  • $\Delta v$: change in velocity (Introduction, Step 1, Step 2, Step 3.1, Step 3.2, Step 5, Step 6, Step 7, Conclusion)
  • $M(t)$: mass of the rocket at time t (Step 1, Step 3.1, Step 5)
  • $v(t)$: velocity of the rocket at time t (Step 1, Step 2, Step 3.1, Step 3.2, Step 5)
  • $P(t)$: initial momentum of the system at time t (Step 1, Step 4)
  • $\Delta m$: mass of fuel expelled (Step 2, Step 3.1, Step 3.2, Step 5)
  • $v_e$: exhaust velocity relative to the rocket (Step 2, Step 3.2, Step 5, Step 6, Step 7, Conclusion)
  • $P_{\text{rocket}}(t + \Delta t)$: momentum of the rocket at time t + $\Delta t$ (Step 3.1, Step 3.2, Step 4)
  • $P_{\text{exhaust}}(t + \Delta t)$: momentum of the exhaust gases at time t + $\Delta t$ (Step 3.2, Step 3.2, Step 4)
  • $P(t + \Delta t)$: total momentum of the system at time t + $\Delta t$ (Step 3.2, Step 4)
  • $dv$: infinitesimal change in velocity (Step 5)
  • $dm$: infinitesimal mass of fuel expelled (Step 5, Step 5)
  • $dM$: infinitesimal change in rocket mass (Step 5)
  • $v_i$: initial velocity (Step 6)
  • $v_f$: final velocity (Step 6)
  • $M_i$: initial mass (Step 6, Step 7)
  • $M_f$: final mass (Step 6, Step 7)

Now, let's create the Latex list.

response

\begin{itemize}
\item $\Delta m$: Mass of fuel expelled as exhaust gases during the time interval $\Delta t$. (Equations \ref{eq:2}, \ref{eq:3}, \ref{eq:4}, \ref{eq:6}, \ref{eq:7})
\item $\Delta v$: Change in the rocket's velocity during the time interval $\Delta t$. (Equations \ref{eq:2}, \ref{eq:4}, \ref{eq:6}, \ref{eq:7}, \ref{eq:13}, \ref{eq:14}, \ref{eq:16}, \ref{eq:17})
\item $dm$: Infinitesimal mass of fuel expelled as exhaust gases. (Equations \ref{eq:8}, \ref{eq:9}, \ref{eq:10})
\item $dM$: Infinitesimal change in the rocket's mass. (Equation \ref{eq:11})
\item $dv$: Infinitesimal change in the rocket's velocity. (Equations \ref{eq:8}, \ref{eq:9}, \ref{eq:10}, \ref{eq:11}, \ref{eq:12})
\item $M(t)$: Mass of the rocket at time $t$. (Equations \ref{eq:1}, \ref{eq:2}, \ref{eq:4}, \ref{eq:6}, \ref{eq:7}, \ref{eq:8}, \ref{eq:9}, \ref{eq:10}, \ref{eq:11})
\item $M_f$: Final mass of the rocket. (Equations \ref{eq:14}, \ref{eq:15}, \ref{eq:16}, \ref{eq:17})
\item $M_i$: Initial mass of the rocket. (Equations \ref{eq:12}, \ref{eq:13}, \ref{eq:14}, \ref{eq:15}, \ref{eq:16}, \ref{eq:17})
\item $P(t)$: Momentum of the system at time $t$. (Equations \ref{eq:1}, \ref{eq:5}, \ref{eq:6})
\item $P(t + \Delta t)$: Momentum of the system at time $t + \Delta t$. (Equations \ref{eq:4}, \ref{eq:5}, \ref{eq:6})
\item $P_{\text{exhaust}}(t + \Delta t)$: Momentum of the exhaust gases at time $t + \Delta t$. (Equations \ref{eq:3}, \ref{eq:4})
\item $P_{\text{rocket}}(t + \Delta t)$: Momentum of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$. (Equations \ref{eq:2}, \ref{eq:4})
\item $v(t)$: Velocity of the rocket at time $t$. (Equations \ref{eq:1}, \ref{eq:2}, \ref{eq:3}, \ref{eq:4}, \ref{eq:6})
\item $v_e$: Exhaust velocity of the expelled gases relative to the rocket. (Equations \ref{eq:3}, \ref{eq:6}, \ref{eq:7}, \ref{eq:8}, \ref{eq:9}, \ref{eq:10}, \ref{eq:11}, \ref{eq:12}, \ref{eq:13}, \ref{eq:14}, \ref{eq:15}, \ref{eq:16}, \ref{eq:17})
\item $v_f$: Final velocity of the rocket. (Equation \ref{eq:12}, \ref{eq:13})
\item $v_i$: Initial velocity of the rocket. (Equation \ref{eq:12}, \ref{eq:13})
\end{itemize}

@bhpayne
Copy link
Member Author

bhpayne commented Jan 26, 2025

Current Latex document:

\documentclass{article}
\usepackage{amsmath}
%\usepackage{amsfonts}
%\usepackage{amssymb}

% margins of 1 inch:
\setlength{\topmargin}{-.5in}
\setlength{\textheight}{9in}
\setlength{\oddsidemargin}{0in}
\setlength{\textwidth}{6.5in}

\usepackage[pdftex]{hyperref} % hyperlink equation and bibliographic citations

\title{Derivation of the Rocket Equation from First Principles}
\author{Ben Payne, with Gemini 2.0}
\date{\today}

\begin{document}
\maketitle

\section{Variables in this Derivation}

\begin{itemize}
    \item $\Delta m$: Mass of fuel expelled as exhaust gases during the time interval $\Delta t$. (Equations \ref{eq:2}, \ref{eq:3}, \ref{eq:4}, \ref{eq:6}, \ref{eq:7})
    \item $\Delta v$: Change in the rocket's velocity during the time interval $\Delta t$. (Equations \ref{eq:2}, \ref{eq:4}, \ref{eq:6}, \ref{eq:7}, \ref{eq:13}, \ref{eq:14}, \ref{eq:16}, \ref{eq:17})
    \item $dm$: Infinitesimal mass of fuel expelled as exhaust gases. (Equations \ref{eq:8}, \ref{eq:9}, \ref{eq:10})
    \item $dM$: Infinitesimal change in the rocket's mass. (Equation \ref{eq:11})
    \item $dv$: Infinitesimal change in the rocket's velocity. (Equations \ref{eq:8}, \ref{eq:9}, \ref{eq:10}, \ref{eq:11}, \ref{eq:12})
    \item $M(t)$: Mass of the rocket at time $t$. (Equations \ref{eq:1}, \ref{eq:2}, \ref{eq:4}, \ref{eq:6}, \ref{eq:7}, \ref{eq:8}, \ref{eq:9}, \ref{eq:10}, \ref{eq:11})
    \item $M_f$: Final mass of the rocket. (Equations \ref{eq:14}, \ref{eq:15}, \ref{eq:16}, \ref{eq:17})
    \item $M_i$: Initial mass of the rocket. (Equations \ref{eq:12}, \ref{eq:13}, \ref{eq:14}, \ref{eq:15}, \ref{eq:16}, \ref{eq:17})
    \item $P(t)$: Momentum of the system at time $t$. (Equations \ref{eq:1}, \ref{eq:5}, \ref{eq:6})
    \item $P(t + \Delta t)$: Momentum of the system at time $t + \Delta t$. (Equations \ref{eq:4}, \ref{eq:5}, \ref{eq:6})
    \item $P_{\text{exhaust}}(t + \Delta t)$: Momentum of the exhaust gases at time $t + \Delta t$. (Equations \ref{eq:3}, \ref{eq:4})
    \item $P_{\text{rocket}}(t + \Delta t)$: Momentum of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$. (Equations \ref{eq:2}, \ref{eq:4})
    \item $v(t)$: Velocity of the rocket at time $t$. (Equations \ref{eq:1}, \ref{eq:2}, \ref{eq:3}, \ref{eq:4}, \ref{eq:6})
    \item $v_e$: Exhaust velocity of the expelled gases relative to the rocket. (Equations \ref{eq:3}, \ref{eq:6}, \ref{eq:7}, \ref{eq:8}, \ref{eq:9}, \ref{eq:10}, \ref{eq:11}, \ref{eq:12}, \ref{eq:13}, \ref{eq:14}, \ref{eq:15}, \ref{eq:16}, \ref{eq:17})
    \item $v_f$: Final velocity of the rocket. (Equation \ref{eq:12}, \ref{eq:13})
    \item $v_i$: Initial velocity of the rocket. (Equation \ref{eq:12}, \ref{eq:13})
\end{itemize}


\section{Introduction}

The rocket equation, also known as the Tsiolkovsky rocket equation, is a fundamental relationship in astronautics that describes the change in velocity ($\Delta v$) a rocket can achieve based on its exhaust velocity and the ratio of its initial and final mass. This derivation starts from first principles, specifically Newton's second law and the conservation of momentum, to arrive at this crucial equation. We will meticulously detail each step and the reasoning behind it.

\section{Define the System and Initial Conditions}

Consider a rocket in free space, far from any gravitational fields or atmospheric drag. This simplifies our analysis by eliminating external forces. We define our system as the rocket \textit{and} the exhaust gases expelled from it. This is crucial for applying the principle of conservation of momentum, as momentum is conserved for a closed system.

At an initial time $t$, let's define the following quantities:
\begin{itemize}
    \item $M(t)$: The mass of the rocket at time $t$. This includes the mass of the rocket structure and the remaining fuel.
    \item $v(t)$: The velocity of the rocket at time $t$ with respect to an inertial reference frame. We will consider motion in one dimension for simplicity, and treat velocity as a scalar.
\end{itemize}
The initial momentum of the system at time $t$, $P(t)$, is simply the momentum of the rocket, as the exhaust gases are initially part of the rocket and moving with it.
\begin{equation}
    P(t) = M(t) v(t)
    \label{eq:1}
\end{equation}

\section{Consider a Small Time Interval $\Delta t$}

Now, consider a small time interval $\Delta t$. During this interval, the rocket expels a small amount of fuel as exhaust gases. We define the following changes and quantities during this interval:
\begin{itemize}
    \item $\Delta m$: The mass of fuel expelled as exhaust gases during the time interval $\Delta t$. Note that $\Delta m$ is a positive quantity.
    \item $\Delta v$: The change in the rocket's velocity during the time interval $\Delta t$. The new velocity of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$ will be $v(t + \Delta t) = v(t) + \Delta v$.
    \item $v_e$: The exhaust velocity of the expelled gases \textit{relative to the rocket}. We assume this exhaust velocity is constant throughout the burn for simplicity.  If the exhaust is directed opposite to the rocket's motion, $v_e$ will be negative in our chosen coordinate system (where the positive direction is the direction of the rocket's velocity). However, for the derivation, we will consider $v_e$ as the magnitude of the exhaust velocity and explicitly consider its direction in our momentum calculations. Let's consider $v_e$ to be directed opposite to the rocket's velocity, so it will be negative.
\end{itemize}

\section{Calculate the Momentum at Time $t + \Delta t$}

At time $t + \Delta t$, we have two components to consider for the momentum of our system: the rocket itself (now with reduced mass and changed velocity) and the expelled exhaust gases.

\subsection{Momentum of the Rocket at $t + \Delta t$}
The mass of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$ is $M(t + \Delta t) = M(t) - \Delta m$. The velocity of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$ is $v(t + \Delta t) = v(t) + \Delta v$. Therefore, the momentum of the rocket at $t + \Delta t$ is:
\begin{equation}
    P_{\text{rocket}}(t + \Delta t) = (M(t) - \Delta m)(v(t) + \Delta v)
    \label{eq:2}
\end{equation}

\subsection{Momentum of the Exhaust Gases at $t + \Delta t$}
We need to find the velocity of the exhaust gases with respect to our inertial reference frame. The exhaust velocity $v_e$ is given relative to the rocket.  Since the rocket's velocity at time $t$ is $v(t)$, and the exhaust is directed opposite to the rocket's motion (in the rocket's frame), the velocity of the exhaust gases in the inertial frame is $v(t) + v_e$.  Since $v_e$ is negative (opposite to the rocket's velocity), this effectively means the exhaust gas velocity in the inertial frame is $v(t) - |v_e|$ if we consider $|v_e|$ as the magnitude of exhaust velocity.  However, keeping $v_e$ as negative exhaust velocity relative to the rocket in the direction of the rocket's motion simplifies the notation. So, the velocity of the exhaust gases in the inertial frame is $v(t) + v_e$. The mass of the exhaust gases is $\Delta m$. Therefore, the momentum of the exhaust gases at $t + \Delta t$ is:
\begin{equation}
    P_{\text{exhaust}}(t + \Delta t) = \Delta m (v(t) + v_e)
    \label{eq:3}
\end{equation}

\subsection{Total Momentum at $t + \Delta t$}
The total momentum of the system at time $t + \Delta t$ is the sum of the momentum of the rocket and the momentum of the exhaust gases:
\begin{equation}
    P(t + \Delta t) = P_{\text{rocket}}(t + \Delta t) + P_{\text{exhaust}}(t + \Delta t) = (M(t) - \Delta m)(v(t) + \Delta v) + \Delta m (v(t) + v_e)
    \label{eq:4}
\end{equation}

\section{Apply Conservation of Momentum}

Since we are considering a closed system in free space with no external forces, the total momentum of the system must be conserved. Therefore, the momentum at time $t$ must be equal to the momentum at time $t + \Delta t$:
\begin{equation}
    P(t) = P(t + \Delta t)
    \label{eq:5}
\end{equation}
Substituting equations \eqref{eq:1} and \eqref{eq:4} into equation \eqref{eq:5}:
\begin{equation}
    M(t) v(t) = (M(t) - \Delta m)(v(t) + \Delta v) + \Delta m (v(t) + v_e)
    \label{eq:6}
\end{equation}

\section{Simplify and Rearrange the Equation}

Expand the right side of equation \eqref{eq:6}:
\begin{align*}
    M(t) v(t) &= M(t)v(t) + M(t)\Delta v - \Delta m v(t) - \Delta m \Delta v + \Delta m v(t) + \Delta m v_e \\
    M(t) v(t) &= M(t)v(t) + M(t)\Delta v - \Delta m \Delta v + \Delta m v_e
\end{align*}
Subtract $M(t)v(t)$ from both sides:
\begin{equation}
    0 = M(t)\Delta v - \Delta m \Delta v + \Delta m v_e
    \label{eq:7}
\end{equation}
We now consider the limit as $\Delta t \rightarrow 0$. In this limit, $\Delta m$ and $\Delta v$ become infinitesimally small, denoted by $dm$ and $dv$ respectively. The term $\Delta m \Delta v$ becomes a second-order infinitesimal and can be neglected compared to the first-order terms $M(t)\Delta v$ and $\Delta m v_e$.  Thus, in the limit, equation \eqref{eq:7} becomes:
\begin{equation}
    0 = M(t)dv + dm v_e
    \label{eq:8}
\end{equation}
Rearranging equation \eqref{eq:8} to solve for $dv$:
\begin{equation}
    M(t)dv = -v_e dm
    \label{eq:9}
\end{equation}
\begin{equation}
    dv = -v_e \frac{dm}{M(t)}
    \label{eq:10}
\end{equation}
Since $dm$ is the mass of fuel expelled, it represents a decrease in the rocket's mass. Therefore, the change in the rocket's mass, $dM$, is negative and equal to $-dm$, i.e., $dM = -dm$. Substituting $dm = -dM$ into equation \eqref{eq:10}:
\begin{equation}
    dv = -v_e \frac{-dM}{M(t)} = v_e \frac{dM}{M(t)}
    \label{eq:11}
\end{equation}
Note that if we take $v_e$ as the magnitude of the exhaust velocity (a positive value), and we consider the exhaust to be in the opposite direction of the rocket's motion, then the direction is accounted for by the negative sign in equation \eqref{eq:9}, making $dv$ positive when $dM$ is negative (mass decreases, velocity increases).  However, if we consider $v_e$ to be negative as initially defined (velocity relative to the rocket in the direction of rocket motion, and exhaust is in the opposite direction, so $v_e < 0$), then equation \eqref{eq:10} and \eqref{eq:11} still hold, and $dv$ will be positive for negative $v_e$ and negative $dM$. For clarity, let's assume $v_e$ is the magnitude of the exhaust velocity, so $v_e > 0$. Then we need to consider the direction explicitly. If the exhaust is in the opposite direction of the rocket's motion, we should write equation \eqref{eq:9} as $Mdv = v_e (-dm)$, where $v_e$ is now the magnitude, and $(-dm)$ is the mass expelled in the direction opposite to the rocket motion in the rocket frame.  Then $dv = -v_e \frac{dm}{M}$ (using $dm$ as positive mass expelled), and since $dM = -dm$, we get $dv = v_e \frac{dM}{M}$.

\section{Integrate to Find the Total Velocity Change}

To find the total change in velocity $\Delta v$ as the rocket mass changes from an initial mass $M_i$ to a final mass $M_f$, we integrate equation \eqref{eq:11}:
\begin{equation}
    \int_{v_i}^{v_f} dv = \int_{M_i}^{M_f} v_e \frac{dM}{M}
    \label{eq:12}
\end{equation}
Assuming the exhaust velocity $v_e$ is constant during the burn, we can take it out of the integral:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = v_f - v_i = v_e \int_{M_i}^{M_f} \frac{dM}{M}
    \label{eq:13}
\end{equation}
The integral of $\frac{1}{M} dM$ is $\ln|M|$. Evaluating the definite integral:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = v_e [\ln|M|]_{M_i}^{M_f} = v_e (\ln|M_f| - \ln|M_i|)
    \label{eq:14}
\end{equation}
Using the property of logarithms $\ln(a) - \ln(b) = \ln\left(\frac{a}{b}\right)$:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = v_e \ln\left(\frac{M_f}{M_i}\right)
    \label{eq:15}
\end{equation}
Since $M_i > M_f$ (the final mass is less than the initial mass after expelling fuel), the ratio $\frac{M_f}{M_i} < 1$, and $\ln\left(\frac{M_f}{M_i}\right)$ will be negative. To have a positive $\Delta v$ (increase in speed in the direction of intended motion if $v_e$ is magnitude), we should write it as:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = -v_e \ln\left(\frac{M_f}{M_i}\right) = v_e \ln\left(\frac{M_i}{M_f}\right)
    \label{eq:16}
\end{equation}
Here, $v_e$ is the magnitude of the exhaust velocity, and $\Delta v$ is the magnitude of the change in rocket velocity.  $\frac{M_i}{M_f}$ is the mass ratio, which is always greater than 1 for a rocket burn, so $\ln\left(\frac{M_i}{M_f}\right) > 0$, and thus $\Delta v > 0$.

\section{The Rocket Equation}

Equation \eqref{eq:16} is the rocket equation. It expresses the change in velocity $\Delta v$ of a rocket as a function of the exhaust velocity $v_e$ and the ratio of the initial mass $M_i$ to the final mass $M_f$.

\textbf{Rocket Equation:}
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = v_e \ln\left(\frac{M_i}{M_f}\right)
    \label{eq:17}
\end{equation}

\section{Conclusion}

We have derived the rocket equation from first principles, starting with the conservation of momentum and considering a small mass of fuel being expelled over a small time interval. By considering the momentum of both the rocket and the exhaust gases before and after the expulsion, and then integrating the resulting differential equation, we arrived at the rocket equation. This equation highlights the key factors influencing a rocket's velocity change: the exhaust velocity and the mass ratio. A higher exhaust velocity and a larger mass ratio (meaning a larger proportion of initial mass is fuel) result in a greater achievable change in velocity. This equation is fundamental for space mission planning and rocket design.

\end{document}

@bhpayne
Copy link
Member Author

bhpayne commented Jan 28, 2025

prompt

For the following Latex file, write out the file and insert a label for each equation. The label that is added should be descriptive of the equation and contain no spaces, only underscores.

Labels for equations should be unique within the document.

The following Latex file contains a derivation with many steps. Sometimes a previous expression is referenced implicitly. Edit the following text to manually insert references where appropriate. For example replace text like "substitute the forces" with "substitute Eq.~\ref{} to get". Be sure to reference the relevant equation labels so that Latex can compile the document.

In the Latex file below, where there are two equations with no explanatory text between them, modify the Latex file by adding explanatory text to document the mathematical transformations that relate each equation in the file to other equations in the file.

Don't provide any commentary. Just write the revised Latex file content as your answer.

\documentclass{article}
\usepackage{amsmath}
%\usepackage{amsfonts}
%\usepackage{amssymb}

% margins of 1 inch:
\setlength{\topmargin}{-.5in}
\setlength{\textheight}{9in}
\setlength{\oddsidemargin}{0in}
\setlength{\textwidth}{6.5in}

\usepackage[pdftex]{hyperref} % hyperlink equation and bibliographic citations

\title{Derivation of the Rocket Equation from First Principles}
\author{Ben Payne, with Gemini 2.0}
\date{\today}

\begin{document}
\maketitle

\section{Introduction}

The rocket equation, also known as the Tsiolkovsky rocket equation, is a fundamental relationship in astronautics that describes the change in velocity ($\Delta v$) a rocket can achieve based on its exhaust velocity and the ratio of its initial and final mass. This derivation starts from first principles, specifically Newton's second law and the conservation of momentum, to arrive at this crucial equation. We will meticulously detail each step and the reasoning behind it.

\section{Define the System and Initial Conditions}

Consider a rocket in free space, far from any gravitational fields or atmospheric drag. This simplifies our analysis by eliminating external forces. We define our system as the rocket \textit{and} the exhaust gases expelled from it. This is crucial for applying the principle of conservation of momentum, as momentum is conserved for a closed system.

At an initial time $t$, let's define the following quantities:
\begin{itemize}
    \item $M(t)$: The mass of the rocket at time $t$. This includes the mass of the rocket structure and the remaining fuel.
    \item $v(t)$: The velocity of the rocket at time $t$ with respect to an inertial reference frame. We will consider motion in one dimension for simplicity, and treat velocity as a scalar.
\end{itemize}
The initial momentum of the system at time $t$, $P(t)$, is simply the momentum of the rocket, as the exhaust gases are initially part of the rocket and moving with it.
\begin{equation}
    P(t) = M(t) v(t)
    \label{eq:1}
\end{equation}

\section{Consider a Small Time Interval \texorpdfstring{$\Delta t$}{Delta t}}

Now, consider a small time interval $\Delta t$. During this interval, the rocket expels a small amount of fuel as exhaust gases. We define the following changes and quantities during this interval:
\begin{itemize}
    \item $\Delta m$: The mass of fuel expelled as exhaust gases during the time interval $\Delta t$. Note that $\Delta m$ is a positive quantity.
    \item $\Delta v$: The change in the rocket's velocity during the time interval $\Delta t$. The new velocity of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$ will be $v(t + \Delta t) = v(t) + \Delta v$.
    \item $v_{\rm exhaust}$: The exhaust velocity of the expelled gases \textit{relative to the rocket}. We assume this exhaust velocity is constant throughout the burn for simplicity.  If the exhaust is directed opposite to the rocket's motion, $v_{\rm exhaust}$ will be negative in our chosen coordinate system (where the positive direction is the direction of the rocket's velocity). However, for the derivation, we will consider $v_{\rm exhaust}$ as the magnitude of the exhaust velocity and explicitly consider its direction in our momentum calculations. Let's consider $v_{\rm exhaust}$ to be directed opposite to the rocket's velocity, so it will be negative.
\end{itemize}

\section{Calculate the Momentum at Time \texorpdfstring{$t+\Delta t$}{t+Delta t}}

At time $t + \Delta t$, we have two components to consider for the momentum of our system: the rocket itself (now with reduced mass and changed velocity) and the expelled exhaust gases.

\subsection{Momentum of the Rocket at \texorpdfstring{$t+\Delta t$}{t+Delta t}}
The mass of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$ is $M(t + \Delta t) = M(t) - \Delta m$. The velocity of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$ is $v(t + \Delta t) = v(t) + \Delta v$. Therefore, the momentum of the rocket at $t + \Delta t$ is:
\begin{equation}
    P_{\text{rocket}}(t + \Delta t) = (M(t) - \Delta m)(v(t) + \Delta v)
    \label{eq:2}
\end{equation}

\subsection{Momentum of the Exhaust Gases at \texorpdfstring{$t+\Delta t$}{t+Delta t}}
We need to find the velocity of the exhaust gases with respect to our inertial reference frame. The exhaust velocity $v_{\rm exhaust}$ is given relative to the rocket.  Since the rocket's velocity at time $t$ is $v(t)$, and the exhaust is directed opposite to the rocket's motion (in the rocket's frame), the velocity of the exhaust gases in the inertial frame is $v(t) + v_{\rm exhaust}$.  Since $v_{\rm exhaust}$ is negative (opposite to the rocket's velocity), this effectively means the exhaust gas velocity in the inertial frame is $v(t) - |v_{\rm exhaust}|$ if we consider $|v_{\rm exhaust}|$ as the magnitude of exhaust velocity.  However, keeping $v_{\rm exhaust}$ as negative exhaust velocity relative to the rocket in the direction of the rocket's motion simplifies the notation. So, the velocity of the exhaust gases in the inertial frame is $v(t) + v_{\rm exhaust}$. The mass of the exhaust gases is $\Delta m$. Therefore, the momentum of the exhaust gases at $t + \Delta t$ is:
\begin{equation}
    P_{\text{exhaust}}(t + \Delta t) = \Delta m (v(t) + v_{\rm exhaust})
    \label{eq:3}
\end{equation}

\subsection{Total Momentum at \texorpdfstring{$t+\Delta t$}{t+Delta t}}
The total momentum of the system at time $t + \Delta t$ is the sum of the momentum of the rocket and the momentum of the exhaust gases:
\begin{equation}
    P(t + \Delta t) = P_{\text{rocket}}(t + \Delta t) + P_{\text{exhaust}}(t + \Delta t) 
    \label{eq:4}
\end{equation}

\begin{equation}
    P(t + \Delta t)  = (M(t) - \Delta m)(v(t) + \Delta v) + \Delta m (v(t) + v_{\rm exhaust})
    \label{eq:45}
\end{equation}

\section{Apply Conservation of Momentum}

Since we are considering a closed system in free space with no external forces, the total momentum of the system must be conserved. Therefore, the momentum at time $t$ must be equal to the momentum at time $t + \Delta t$:
\begin{equation}
    P(t) = P(t + \Delta t)
    \label{eq:5}
\end{equation}
Substituting equations \eqref{eq:1} and \eqref{eq:4} into equation \eqref{eq:5}:
\begin{equation}
    M(t) v(t) = (M(t) - \Delta m)(v(t) + \Delta v) + \Delta m (v(t) + v_{\rm exhaust})
    \label{eq:6}
\end{equation}

\section{Simplify and Rearrange the Equation}

Expand the right side of equation \eqref{eq:6}:
\begin{equation}
    M(t) v(t) = M(t)v(t) + M(t)\Delta v - \Delta m v(t) - \Delta m \Delta v + \Delta m v(t) + \Delta m v_{\rm exhaust} 
\end{equation}

\begin{equation}
    M(t) v(t) = M(t)v(t) + M(t)\Delta v - \Delta m \Delta v + \Delta m v_{\rm exhaust}
\end{equation}
Subtract $M(t)v(t)$ from both sides:
\begin{equation}
    0 = M(t)\Delta v - \Delta m \Delta v + \Delta m v_{\rm exhaust}
    \label{eq:7}
\end{equation}
We now consider the limit as $\Delta t \rightarrow 0$. In this limit, $\Delta m$ and $\Delta v$ become infinitesimally small, denoted by $dm$ and $dv$ respectively. The term $\Delta m \Delta v$ becomes a second-order infinitesimal and can be neglected compared to the first-order terms $M(t)\Delta v$ and $\Delta m v_{\rm exhaust}$.  Thus, in the limit, equation \eqref{eq:7} becomes:
\begin{equation}
    0 = M(t)dv +  v_{\rm exhaust} dm
    \label{eq:8}
\end{equation}
Rearranging equation \eqref{eq:8} to solve for $dv$:
\begin{equation}
    M(t)dv = -v_{\rm exhaust} dm
    \label{eq:9}
\end{equation}
\begin{equation}
    dv = -v_{\rm exhaust} \frac{dm}{M(t)}
    \label{eq:10}
\end{equation}
Since $dm$ is the mass of fuel expelled, it represents a decrease in the rocket's mass. Therefore, the change in the rocket's mass, $dM$, is negative and equal to $-dm$, i.e., $dM = -dm$. Substituting $dm = -dM$ into equation \eqref{eq:10}:
\begin{equation}
    dv = -v_{\rm exhaust} \frac{-dM}{M(t)} = v_{\rm exhaust} \frac{dM}{M(t)}
    \label{eq:11}
\end{equation}
Note that if we take $v_{\rm exhaust}$ as the magnitude of the exhaust velocity (a positive value), and we consider the exhaust to be in the opposite direction of the rocket's motion, then the direction is accounted for by the negative sign in equation \eqref{eq:9}, making $dv$ positive when $dM$ is negative (mass decreases, velocity increases).  However, if we consider $v_{\rm exhaust}$ to be negative as initially defined (velocity relative to the rocket in the direction of rocket motion, and exhaust is in the opposite direction, so $v_{\rm exhaust} < 0$), then equation \eqref{eq:10} and \eqref{eq:11} still hold, and $dv$ will be positive for negative $v_{\rm exhaust}$ and negative $dM$. For clarity, let's assume $v_{\rm exhaust}$ is the magnitude of the exhaust velocity, so $v_{\rm exhaust} > 0$. Then we need to consider the direction explicitly. If the exhaust is in the opposite direction of the rocket's motion, we should write equation \eqref{eq:9} as $Mdv = v_{\rm exhaust} (-dm)$, where $v_{\rm exhaust}$ is now the magnitude, and $(-dm)$ is the mass expelled in the direction opposite to the rocket motion in the rocket frame.  Then $dv = -v_{\rm exhaust} \frac{dm}{M}$ (using $dm$ as positive mass expelled), and since $dM = -dm$, we get $dv = v_{\rm exhaust} \frac{dM}{M}$.

\section{Integrate to Find the Total Velocity Change}

To find the total change in velocity $\Delta v$ as the rocket mass changes from an initial mass $M_i$ to a final mass $M_f$, we integrate equation \eqref{eq:11}:
\begin{equation}
    \int_{v_i}^{v_f} dv = \int_{M_i}^{M_f} v_{\rm exhaust} \frac{dM}{M}
    \label{eq:12}
\end{equation}
Assuming the exhaust velocity $v_{\rm exhaust}$ is constant during the burn, we can take it out of the integral:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = v_f - v_i = v_{\rm exhaust} \int_{M_i}^{M_f} \frac{dM}{M}
    \label{eq:13}
\end{equation}
The integral of $\frac{1}{M} dM$ is $\ln|M|$. 
\begin{equation}
    \int \frac{1}{M} dM = \ln|M|
\end{equation}

Evaluating the definite integral:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = v_{\rm exhaust} [\ln|M|]_{M_i}^{M_f} 
    \label{eq:14}
\end{equation}
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v  = v_{\rm exhaust} (\ln|M_f| - \ln|M_i|)
    \label{eq:14-2}
\end{equation}
Using the property of logarithms 
\begin{equation}
    \ln(a) - \ln(b) = \ln\left(\frac{a}{b}\right)
\end{equation}

\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = v_{\rm exhaust} \ln\left(\frac{M_f}{M_i}\right)
    \label{eq:15}
\end{equation}
Since $M_i > M_f$ (the final mass is less than the initial mass after expelling fuel), the ratio $\frac{M_f}{M_i} < 1$, and $\ln\left(\frac{M_f}{M_i}\right)$ will be negative. To have a positive $\Delta v$ (increase in speed in the direction of intended motion if $v_{\rm exhaust}$ is magnitude), we should write it as:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = -v_{\rm exhaust} \ln\left(\frac{M_f}{M_i}\right) 
    \label{eq:16}
\end{equation}
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v =  v_{\rm exhaust} \ln\left(\frac{M_i}{M_f}\right)
    \label{eq:16-2}
\end{equation}
Here, $v_{\rm exhaust}$ is the magnitude of the exhaust velocity, and $\Delta v$ is the magnitude of the change in rocket velocity.  $\frac{M_i}{M_f}$ is the mass ratio, which is always greater than 1 for a rocket burn, so $\ln\left(\frac{M_i}{M_f}\right) > 0$, and thus $\Delta v > 0$.

\section{The Rocket Equation}

Equation \eqref{eq:16} is the rocket equation. It expresses the change in velocity $\Delta v$ of a rocket as a function of the exhaust velocity $v_{\rm exhaust}$ and the ratio of the initial mass $M_i$ to the final mass $M_f$.

\textbf{Rocket Equation:}
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = v_{\rm exhaust} \ln\left(\frac{M_i}{M_f}\right)
    \label{eq:17}
\end{equation}

\section{Conclusion}

We have derived the rocket equation from first principles, starting with the conservation of momentum and considering a small mass of fuel being expelled over a small time interval. By considering the momentum of both the rocket and the exhaust gases before and after the expulsion, and then integrating the resulting differential equation, we arrived at the rocket equation. This equation highlights the key factors influencing a rocket's velocity change: the exhaust velocity and the mass ratio. A higher exhaust velocity and a larger mass ratio (meaning a larger proportion of initial mass is fuel) result in a greater achievable change in velocity. This equation is fundamental for space mission planning and rocket design.

\end{document}

thoughts

The user wants me to modify a Latex file.
I need to perform three tasks:

  1. Add a descriptive label to each equation in the Latex file. The labels should be unique, contain no spaces and only use underscores.
  2. Insert references to equations where previous expressions are implicitly referenced. I need to replace phrases like "substitute the forces" with "substitute Eq.~\ref{}" and make sure to use the correct label.
  3. Add explanatory text between two consecutive equations where there is no text. The explanatory text should describe the mathematical transformation between the equations.

Let's go through the Latex file section by section and apply these changes.

Section: Define the System and Initial Conditions

  • Equation: P(t) = M(t) v(t)
    • Label: initial_momentum
    • No references needed.

**Section: Consider a Small Time Interval \texorpdfstring{$\Delta t$}{Delta t}}

  • No equations in this section.

**Section: Calculate the Momentum at Time \texorpdfstring{$t+\Delta t$}{t+Delta t}}

  • Subsection: Momentum of the Rocket at \texorpdfstring{$t+\Delta t$}{t+Delta t}
    • Equation: P_{\text{rocket}}(t + \Delta t) = (M(t) - \Delta m)(v(t) + \Delta v)
      • Label: momentum_rocket_time_dt
      • No references needed.
  • Subsection: Momentum of the Exhaust Gases at \texorpdfstring{$t+\Delta t$}{t+Delta t}
    • Equation: P_{\text{exhaust}}(t + \Delta t) = \Delta m (v(t) + v_{\rm exhaust})
      • Label: momentum_exhaust_time_dt
      • No references needed.
  • Subsection: Total Momentum at \texorpdfstring{$t+\Delta t$}{t+Delta t}
    • Equation: P(t + \Delta t) = P_{\text{rocket}}(t + \Delta t) + P_{\text{exhaust}}(t + \Delta t)
      • Label: total_momentum_time_dt_sum
      • Reference: "the sum of the momentum of the rocket and the momentum of the exhaust gases" can be replaced with "the sum of Eq.\ref{momentum_rocket_time_dt} and Eq.\ref{momentum_exhaust_time_dt}".
    • Equation: P(t + \Delta t) = (M(t) - \Delta m)(v(t) + \Delta v) + \Delta m (v(t) + v_{\rm exhaust})
      • Label: total_momentum_time_dt_expanded
      • Explanatory text needed: This equation is obtained by substituting Eq.\ref{momentum_rocket_time_dt} and Eq.\ref{momentum_exhaust_time_dt} into Eq.~\ref{total_momentum_time_dt_sum}.

Section: Apply Conservation of Momentum

  • Equation: P(t) = P(t + \Delta t)
    • Label: conservation_momentum
    • No references needed.
  • Equation: M(t) v(t) = (M(t) - \Delta m)(v(t) + \Delta v) + \Delta m (v(t) + v_{\rm exhaust})
    • Label: momentum_equality
    • Reference: "Substituting equations \eqref{eq:1} and \eqref{eq:4} into equation \eqref{eq:5}" should be "Substituting Eq.\ref{initial_momentum} and Eq.\ref{total_momentum_time_dt_sum} into Eq.~\ref{conservation_momentum}".

Section: Simplify and Rearrange the Equation

  • Equation: M(t) v(t) = M(t)v(t) + M(t)\Delta v - \Delta m v(t) - \Delta m \Delta v + \Delta m v(t) + \Delta m v_{\rm exhaust}
    • Label: expanded_momentum_equality_step1
    • Explanatory text needed: This equation is obtained by expanding the right side of Eq.~\ref{momentum_equality}.
  • Equation: M(t) v(t) = M(t)v(t) + M(t)\Delta v - \Delta m \Delta v + \Delta m v_{\rm exhaust}
    • Label: expanded_momentum_equality_step2
    • Explanatory text needed: This equation is obtained by simplifying Eq.~\ref{expanded_momentum_equality_step1}.
  • Equation: 0 = M(t)\Delta v - \Delta m \Delta v + \Delta m v_{\rm exhaust}
    • Label: simplified_momentum_equation_delta
    • Explanatory text needed: This equation is obtained by subtracting $M(t)v(t)$ from both sides of Eq.~\ref{expanded_momentum_equality_step2}.
  • Equation: 0 = M(t)dv + v_{\rm exhaust} dm
    • Label: simplified_momentum_equation_differential
    • Reference: "Thus, in the limit, equation \eqref{eq:7} becomes:" should be "Thus, in the limit, Eq.~\ref{simplified_momentum_equation_delta} becomes:".
  • Equation: M(t)dv = -v_{\rm exhaust} dm
    • Label: rearranged_momentum_equation_dv
    • Explanatory text needed: This equation is obtained by rearranging Eq.~\ref{simplified_momentum_equation_differential}.
  • Equation: dv = -v_{\rm exhaust} \frac{dm}{M(t)}
    • Label: dv_equation_dm
    • Explanatory text needed: This equation is obtained by dividing both sides of Eq.~\ref{rearranged_momentum_equation_dv} by $M(t)$.
  • Equation: dv = -v_{\rm exhaust} \frac{-dM}{M(t)} = v_{\rm exhaust} \frac{dM}{M(t)}
    • Label: dv_equation_dM
    • Reference: "Substituting $dm = -dM$ into equation \eqref{eq:10}" should be "Substituting $dm = -dM$ into Eq.~\ref{dv_equation_dm}".

Section: Integrate to Find the Total Velocity Change

  • Equation: \int_{v_i}^{v_f} dv = \int_{M_i}^{M_f} v_{\rm exhaust} \frac{dM}{M}
    • Label: integral_dv_dM
    • Reference: "To find the total change in velocity ... we integrate equation \eqref{eq:11}" should be "To find the total change in velocity ... we integrate Eq.~\ref{dv_equation_dM}".
  • Equation: \Delta v = v_f - v_i = v_{\rm exhaust} \int_{M_i}^{M_f} \frac{dM}{M}
    • Label: delta_v_integral
    • Explanatory text needed: This equation is obtained by taking $v_{\rm exhaust}$ out of the integral in Eq.~\ref{integral_dv_dM} and evaluating the left integral.
  • Equation: \int \frac{1}{M} dM = \ln|M|
    • Label: integral_1_over_M
    • No references needed.
  • Equation: \Delta v = v_{\rm exhaust} [\ln|M|]_{M_i}^{M_f}
    • Label: delta_v_evaluated_integral_step1
    • Reference: "Evaluating the definite integral:" should be "Evaluating the definite integral in Eq.~\ref{delta_v_integral}:"
  • Equation: \Delta v = v_{\rm exhaust} (\ln|M_f| - \ln|M_i|)
    • Label: delta_v_evaluated_integral_step2
    • Explanatory text needed: This equation is obtained by evaluating the definite integral in Eq.~\ref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step1}.
  • Equation: \ln(a) - \ln(b) = \ln\left(\frac{a}{b}\right)
    • Label: logarithm_property
    • No references needed.
  • Equation: \Delta v = v_{\rm exhaust} \ln\left(\frac{M_f}{M_i}\right)
    • Label: delta_v_log_ratio_step1
    • Reference: "Using the property of logarithms" should be "Using the logarithm property from Eq.~\ref{logarithm_property}".
  • Equation: \Delta v = -v_{\rm exhaust} \ln\left(\frac{M_f}{M_i}\right)
    • Label: delta_v_negative_log
    • No explanatory text needed.
  • Equation: \Delta v = v_{\rm exhaust} \ln\left(\frac{M_i}{M_f}\right)
    • Label: rocket_equation_step1
    • Explanatory text needed: This equation is obtained by using the property of logarithms and multiplying by $-1$ in Eq.~\ref{delta_v_negative_log}.

Section: The Rocket Equation

  • Equation: \Delta v = v_{\rm exhaust} \ln\left(\frac{M_i}{M_f}\right)
    • Label: rocket_equation_final
    • Reference: "Equation \eqref{eq:16} is the rocket equation." should be "Equation \eqref{rocket_equation_step1} is the rocket equation." and "(Equation \eqref{eq:17} is the rocket equation.)" should be "(Equation \eqref{rocket_equation_final} is the rocket equation.)".

Now I will write out the revised Latex file content by incorporating all the changes.

response

\documentclass{article}
\usepackage{amsmath}
%\usepackage{amsfonts}
%\usepackage{amssymb}

% margins of 1 inch:
\setlength{\topmargin}{-.5in}
\setlength{\textheight}{9in}
\setlength{\oddsidemargin}{0in}
\setlength{\textwidth}{6.5in}

\usepackage[pdftex]{hyperref} % hyperlink equation and bibliographic citations

\title{Derivation of the Rocket Equation from First Principles}
\author{Ben Payne, with Gemini 2.0}
\date{\today}

\begin{document}
\maketitle

\section{Introduction}

The rocket equation, also known as the Tsiolkovsky rocket equation, is a fundamental relationship in astronautics that describes the change in velocity ($\Delta v$) a rocket can achieve based on its exhaust velocity and the ratio of its initial and final mass. This derivation starts from first principles, specifically Newton's second law and the conservation of momentum, to arrive at this crucial equation. We will meticulously detail each step and the reasoning behind it.

\section{Define the System and Initial Conditions}

Consider a rocket in free space, far from any gravitational fields or atmospheric drag. This simplifies our analysis by eliminating external forces. We define our system as the rocket \textit{and} the exhaust gases expelled from it. This is crucial for applying the principle of conservation of momentum, as momentum is conserved for a closed system.

At an initial time $t$, let's define the following quantities:
\begin{itemize}
    \item $M(t)$: The mass of the rocket at time $t$. This includes the mass of the rocket structure and the remaining fuel.
    \item $v(t)$: The velocity of the rocket at time $t$ with respect to an inertial reference frame. We will consider motion in one dimension for simplicity, and treat velocity as a scalar.
\end{itemize}
The initial momentum of the system at time $t$, $P(t)$, is simply the momentum of the rocket, as the exhaust gases are initially part of the rocket and moving with it.
\begin{equation}
    P(t) = M(t) v(t)
    \label{initial_momentum}
\end{equation}

\section{Consider a Small Time Interval \texorpdfstring{$\Delta t$}{Delta t}}

Now, consider a small time interval $\Delta t$. During this interval, the rocket expels a small amount of fuel as exhaust gases. We define the following changes and quantities during this interval:
\begin{itemize}
    \item $\Delta m$: The mass of fuel expelled as exhaust gases during the time interval $\Delta t$. Note that $\Delta m$ is a positive quantity.
    \item $\Delta v$: The change in the rocket's velocity during the time interval $\Delta t$. The new velocity of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$ will be $v(t + \Delta t) = v(t) + \Delta v$.
    \item $v_{\rm exhaust}$: The exhaust velocity of the expelled gases \textit{relative to the rocket}. We assume this exhaust velocity is constant throughout the burn for simplicity.  If the exhaust is directed opposite to the rocket's motion, $v_{\rm exhaust}$ will be negative in our chosen coordinate system (where the positive direction is the direction of the rocket's velocity). However, for the derivation, we will consider $v_{\rm exhaust}$ as the magnitude of the exhaust velocity and explicitly consider its direction in our momentum calculations. Let's consider $v_{\rm exhaust}$ to be directed opposite to the rocket's velocity, so it will be negative.
\end{itemize}

\section{Calculate the Momentum at Time \texorpdfstring{$t+\Delta t$}{t+Delta t}}

At time $t + \Delta t$, we have two components to consider for the momentum of our system: the rocket itself (now with reduced mass and changed velocity) and the expelled exhaust gases.

\subsection{Momentum of the Rocket at \texorpdfstring{$t+\Delta t$}{t+Delta t}}
The mass of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$ is $M(t + \Delta t) = M(t) - \Delta m$. The velocity of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$ is $v(t + \Delta t) = v(t) + \Delta v$. Therefore, the momentum of the rocket at $t + \Delta t$ is:
\begin{equation}
    P_{\text{rocket}}(t + \Delta t) = (M(t) - \Delta m)(v(t) + \Delta v)
    \label{momentum_rocket_time_dt}
\end{equation}

\subsection{Momentum of the Exhaust Gases at \texorpdfstring{$t+\Delta t$}{t+Delta t}}
We need to find the velocity of the exhaust gases with respect to our inertial reference frame. The exhaust velocity $v_{\rm exhaust}$ is given relative to the rocket.  Since the rocket's velocity at time $t$ is $v(t)$, and the exhaust is directed opposite to the rocket's motion (in the rocket's frame), the velocity of the exhaust gases in the inertial frame is $v(t) + v_{\rm exhaust}$.  Since $v_{\rm exhaust}$ is negative (opposite to the rocket's velocity), this effectively means the exhaust gas velocity in the inertial frame is $v(t) - |v_{\rm exhaust}|$ if we consider $|v_{\rm exhaust}|$ as the magnitude of exhaust velocity.  However, keeping $v_{\rm exhaust}$ as negative exhaust velocity relative to the rocket in the direction of the rocket's motion simplifies the notation. So, the velocity of the exhaust gases in the inertial frame is $v(t) + v_{\rm exhaust}$. The mass of the exhaust gases is $\Delta m$. Therefore, the momentum of the exhaust gases at $t + \Delta t$ is:
\begin{equation}
    P_{\text{exhaust}}(t + \Delta t) = \Delta m (v(t) + v_{\rm exhaust})
    \label{momentum_exhaust_time_dt}
\end{equation}

\subsection{Total Momentum at \texorpdfstring{$t+\Delta t$}{t+Delta t}}
The total momentum of the system at time $t + \Delta t$ is the sum of the momentum of the rocket and the momentum of the exhaust gases:
\begin{equation}
    P(t + \Delta t) = P_{\text{rocket}}(t + \Delta t) + P_{\text{exhaust}}(t + \Delta t)
    \label{total_momentum_time_dt_sum}
\end{equation}
Substituting Eq.~\ref{momentum_rocket_time_dt} and Eq.~\ref{momentum_exhaust_time_dt} into Eq.~\ref{total_momentum_time_dt_sum} to get:
\begin{equation}
    P(t + \Delta t)  = (M(t) - \Delta m)(v(t) + \Delta v) + \Delta m (v(t) + v_{\rm exhaust})
    \label{total_momentum_time_dt_expanded}
\end{equation}

\section{Apply Conservation of Momentum}

Since we are considering a closed system in free space with no external forces, the total momentum of the system must be conserved. Therefore, the momentum at time $t$ must be equal to the momentum at time $t + \Delta t$:
\begin{equation}
    P(t) = P(t + \Delta t)
    \label{conservation_momentum}
\end{equation}
Substituting Eq.~\ref{initial_momentum} and Eq.~\ref{total_momentum_time_dt_sum} into Eq.~\ref{conservation_momentum}:
\begin{equation}
    M(t) v(t) = (M(t) - \Delta m)(v(t) + \Delta v) + \Delta m (v(t) + v_{\rm exhaust})
    \label{momentum_equality}
\end{equation}

\section{Simplify and Rearrange the Equation}

Expanding the right side of Eq.~\ref{momentum_equality} we get:
\begin{equation}
    M(t) v(t) = M(t)v(t) + M(t)\Delta v - \Delta m v(t) - \Delta m \Delta v + \Delta m v(t) + \Delta m v_{\rm exhaust}
    \label{expanded_momentum_equality_step1}
\end{equation}
Simplifying Eq.~\ref{expanded_momentum_equality_step1} by cancelling terms we get:
\begin{equation}
    M(t) v(t) = M(t)v(t) + M(t)\Delta v - \Delta m \Delta v + \Delta m v_{\rm exhaust}
    \label{expanded_momentum_equality_step2}
\end{equation}
Subtracting $M(t)v(t)$ from both sides of Eq.~\ref{expanded_momentum_equality_step2} gives:
\begin{equation}
    0 = M(t)\Delta v - \Delta m \Delta v + \Delta m v_{\rm exhaust}
    \label{simplified_momentum_equation_delta}
\end{equation}
We now consider the limit as $\Delta t \rightarrow 0$. In this limit, $\Delta m$ and $\Delta v$ become infinitesimally small, denoted by $dm$ and $dv$ respectively. The term $\Delta m \Delta v$ becomes a second-order infinitesimal and can be neglected compared to the first-order terms $M(t)\Delta v$ and $\Delta m v_{\rm exhaust}$.  Thus, in the limit, Eq.~\ref{simplified_momentum_equation_delta} becomes:
\begin{equation}
    0 = M(t)dv +  v_{\rm exhaust} dm
    \label{simplified_momentum_equation_differential}
\end{equation}
Rearranging Eq.~\ref{simplified_momentum_equation_differential} to solve for $dv$:
\begin{equation}
    M(t)dv = -v_{\rm exhaust} dm
    \label{rearranged_momentum_equation_dv}
\end{equation}
Dividing both sides of Eq.~\ref{rearranged_momentum_equation_dv} by $M(t)$ we get:
\begin{equation}
    dv = -v_{\rm exhaust} \frac{dm}{M(t)}
    \label{dv_equation_dm}
\end{equation}
Since $dm$ is the mass of fuel expelled, it represents a decrease in the rocket's mass. Therefore, the change in the rocket's mass, $dM$, is negative and equal to $-dm$, i.e., $dM = -dm$. Substituting $dm = -dM$ into Eq.~\ref{dv_equation_dm}:
\begin{equation}
    dv = -v_{\rm exhaust} \frac{-dM}{M(t)} = v_{\rm exhaust} \frac{dM}{M(t)}
    \label{dv_equation_dM}
\end{equation}
Note that if we take $v_{\rm exhaust}$ as the magnitude of the exhaust velocity (a positive value), and we consider the exhaust to be in the opposite direction of the rocket's motion, then the direction is accounted for by the negative sign in equation \eqref{rearranged_momentum_equation_dv}, making $dv$ positive when $dM$ is negative (mass decreases, velocity increases).  However, if we consider $v_{\rm exhaust}$ to be negative as initially defined (velocity relative to the rocket in the direction of rocket motion, and exhaust is in the opposite direction, so $v_{\rm exhaust} < 0$), then Eq.~\ref{dv_equation_dm} and \eqref{dv_equation_dM} still hold, and $dv$ will be positive for negative $v_{\rm exhaust}$ and negative $dM$. For clarity, let's assume $v_{\rm exhaust}$ is the magnitude of the exhaust velocity, so $v_{\rm exhaust} > 0$. Then we need to consider the direction explicitly. If the exhaust is in the opposite direction of the rocket's motion, we should write equation \eqref{rearranged_momentum_equation_dv} as $Mdv = v_{\rm exhaust} (-dm)$, where $v_{\rm exhaust}$ is now the magnitude, and $(-dm)$ is the mass expelled in the direction opposite to the rocket motion in the rocket frame.  Then $dv = -v_{\rm exhaust} \frac{dm}{M}$ (using $dm$ as positive mass expelled), and since $dM = -dm$, we get $dv = v_{\rm exhaust} \frac{dM}{M}$.

\section{Integrate to Find the Total Velocity Change}

To find the total change in velocity $\Delta v$ as the rocket mass changes from an initial mass $M_i$ to a final mass $M_f$, we integrate Eq.~\ref{dv_equation_dM}:
\begin{equation}
    \int_{v_i}^{v_f} dv = \int_{M_i}^{M_f} v_{\rm exhaust} \frac{dM}{M}
    \label{integral_dv_dM}
\end{equation}
Taking $v_{\rm exhaust}$ out of the integral in Eq.~\ref{integral_dv_dM} and evaluating the left integral, we get:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = v_f - v_i = v_{\rm exhaust} \int_{M_i}^{M_f} \frac{dM}{M}
    \label{delta_v_integral}
\end{equation}
The integral of $\frac{1}{M} dM$ is $\ln|M|$.
\begin{equation}
    \int \frac{1}{M} dM = \ln|M|
    \label{integral_1_over_M}
\end{equation}

Evaluating the definite integral in Eq.~\ref{delta_v_integral}:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = v_{\rm exhaust} [\ln|M|]_{M_i}^{M_f}
    \label{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step1}
\end{equation}
Evaluating the definite integral in Eq.~\ref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step1} we get:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v  = v_{\rm exhaust} (\ln|M_f| - \ln|M_i|)
    \label{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step2}
\end{equation}
Using the logarithm property from Eq.~\ref{logarithm_property}
\begin{equation}
    \ln(a) - \ln(b) = \ln\left(\frac{a}{b}\right)
    \label{logarithm_property}
\end{equation}
and applying it to Eq.~\ref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step2} we have:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = v_{\rm exhaust} \ln\left(\frac{M_f}{M_i}\right)
    \label{delta_v_log_ratio_step1}
\end{equation}
Using the property of logarithms and multiplying by $-1$ in Eq.~\ref{delta_v_log_ratio_step1} we get:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = -v_{\rm exhaust} \ln\left(\frac{M_f}{M_i}\right)
    \label{delta_v_negative_log}
\end{equation}
Using the property of logarithms and multiplying by $-1$ in Eq.~\ref{delta_v_negative_log} we get:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v =  v_{\rm exhaust} \ln\left(\frac{M_i}{M_f}\right)
    \label{rocket_equation_step1}
\end{equation}

\section{The Rocket Equation}

Equation \eqref{rocket_equation_step1} is the rocket equation. It expresses the change in velocity $\Delta v$ of a rocket as a function of the exhaust velocity $v_{\rm exhaust}$ and the ratio of the initial mass $M_i$ to the final mass $M_f$.

\textbf{Rocket Equation:}
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = v_{\rm exhaust} \ln\left(\frac{M_i}{M_f}\right)
    \label{rocket_equation_final}
\end{equation}

\section{Conclusion}

We have derived the rocket equation from first principles, starting with the conservation of momentum and considering a small mass of fuel being expelled over a small time interval. By considering the momentum of both the rocket and the exhaust gases before and after the expulsion, and then integrating the resulting differential equation, we arrived at the rocket equation. This equation highlights the key factors influencing a rocket's velocity change: the exhaust velocity and the mass ratio. A higher exhaust velocity and a larger mass ratio (meaning a larger proportion of initial mass is fuel) result in a greater achievable change in velocity. This equation is fundamental for space mission planning and rocket design.

\end{document}

@bhpayne
Copy link
Member Author

bhpayne commented Jan 28, 2025

prompt

The following latex file contains equations and variables. Provide a list, formatted as Latex, of every unique variable and a description of that variable.

For each entry in the list include a reference to the labeled equations where each variable is used. Write out just the Latex list as your answer.

\documentclass{article}
\usepackage{amsmath}
%\usepackage{amsfonts}
%\usepackage{amssymb}

% margins of 1 inch:
\setlength{\topmargin}{-.5in}
\setlength{\textheight}{9in}
\setlength{\oddsidemargin}{0in}
\setlength{\textwidth}{6.5in}

\usepackage[pdftex]{hyperref} % hyperlink equation and bibliographic citations

\title{Derivation of the Rocket Equation from First Principles}
\author{Ben Payne, with Gemini 2.0}
\date{\today}

\begin{document}
\maketitle

\section{Introduction}

The rocket equation, also known as the Tsiolkovsky rocket equation, is a fundamental relationship in astronautics that describes the change in velocity ($\Delta v$) a rocket can achieve based on its exhaust velocity and the ratio of its initial and final mass. This derivation starts from first principles, specifically Newton's second law and the conservation of momentum, to arrive at this crucial equation. We will meticulously detail each step and the reasoning behind it.

\section{Define the System and Initial Conditions}

Consider a rocket in free space, far from any gravitational fields or atmospheric drag. This simplifies our analysis by eliminating external forces. We define our system as the rocket \textit{and} the exhaust gases expelled from it. This is crucial for applying the principle of conservation of momentum, as momentum is conserved for a closed system.

At an initial time $t$, let's define the following quantities:
\begin{itemize}
    \item $M(t)$: The mass of the rocket at time $t$. This includes the mass of the rocket structure and the remaining fuel.
    \item $v(t)$: The velocity of the rocket at time $t$ with respect to an inertial reference frame. We will consider motion in one dimension for simplicity, and treat velocity as a scalar.
\end{itemize}
The initial momentum of the system at time $t$, $P(t)$, is simply the momentum of the rocket, as the exhaust gases are initially part of the rocket and moving with it.
\begin{equation}
    P(t) = M(t) v(t)
    \label{initial_momentum}
\end{equation}

\section{Consider a Small Time Interval \texorpdfstring{$\Delta t$}{Delta t}}

Now, consider a small time interval $\Delta t$. During this interval, the rocket expels a small amount of fuel as exhaust gases. We define the following changes and quantities during this interval:
\begin{itemize}
    \item $\Delta m$: The mass of fuel expelled as exhaust gases during the time interval $\Delta t$. Note that $\Delta m$ is a positive quantity.
    \item $\Delta v$: The change in the rocket's velocity during the time interval $\Delta t$. The new velocity of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$ will be
\begin{equation}
    v(t + \Delta t) = v(t) + \Delta v
    \label{eq:new_velocity}
\end{equation}
    
    \item $v_{\rm exhaust}$: The exhaust velocity of the expelled gases \textit{relative to the rocket}. We assume this exhaust velocity is constant throughout the burn for simplicity.  If the exhaust is directed opposite to the rocket's motion, $v_{\rm exhaust}$ will be negative in our chosen coordinate system (where the positive direction is the direction of the rocket's velocity). However, for the derivation, we will consider $v_{\rm exhaust}$ as the magnitude of the exhaust velocity and explicitly consider its direction in our momentum calculations. Let's consider $v_{\rm exhaust}$ to be directed opposite to the rocket's velocity, so it will be negative.
\end{itemize}

\section{Calculate the Momentum at Time \texorpdfstring{$t+\Delta t$}{t+Delta t}}

At time $t + \Delta t$, we have two components to consider for the momentum of our system: the rocket itself (now with reduced mass and changed velocity) and the expelled exhaust gases.

\subsection{Momentum of the Rocket at \texorpdfstring{$t+\Delta t$}{t+Delta t}}
The mass of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$ is 
\begin{equation}
    M(t + \Delta t) = M(t) - \Delta m
    \label{eq:mass_later}
\end{equation}
The velocity of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$ is
\begin{equation}
 v(t + \Delta t) = v(t) + \Delta v
    \label{eq:velocity_later}
\end{equation}
Therefore, the momentum of the rocket at $t + \Delta t$ is:
\begin{equation}
    P_{\text{rocket}}(t + \Delta t) = (M(t) - \Delta m)(v(t) + \Delta v)
    \label{momentum_rocket_time_dt}
\end{equation}

\subsection{Momentum of the Exhaust Gases at \texorpdfstring{$t+\Delta t$}{t+Delta t}}
We need to find the velocity of the exhaust gases with respect to our inertial reference frame. The exhaust velocity $v_{\rm exhaust}$ is given relative to the rocket.  Since the rocket's velocity at time $t$ is $v(t)$, and the exhaust is directed opposite to the rocket's motion (in the rocket's frame), the velocity of the exhaust gases in the inertial frame is $v(t) + v_{\rm exhaust}$.  Since $v_{\rm exhaust}$ is negative (opposite to the rocket's velocity), this effectively means the exhaust gas velocity in the inertial frame is $v(t) - |v_{\rm exhaust}|$ if we consider $|v_{\rm exhaust}|$ as the magnitude of exhaust velocity.  However, keeping $v_{\rm exhaust}$ as negative exhaust velocity relative to the rocket in the direction of the rocket's motion simplifies the notation. So, the velocity of the exhaust gases in the inertial frame is $v(t) + v_{\rm exhaust}$. The mass of the exhaust gases is $\Delta m$. Therefore, the momentum of the exhaust gases at $t + \Delta t$ is:
\begin{equation}
    P_{\text{exhaust}}(t + \Delta t) = \Delta m (v(t) + v_{\rm exhaust})
    \label{momentum_exhaust_time_dt}
\end{equation}

\subsection{Total Momentum at \texorpdfstring{$t+\Delta t$}{t+Delta t}}
The total momentum of the system at time $t + \Delta t$ is the sum of the momentum of the rocket and the momentum of the exhaust gases:
\begin{equation}
    P(t + \Delta t) = P_{\text{rocket}}(t + \Delta t) + P_{\text{exhaust}}(t + \Delta t)
    \label{total_momentum_time_dt_sum}
\end{equation}
Substituting Eq.~\ref{momentum_rocket_time_dt} and Eq.~\ref{momentum_exhaust_time_dt} into Eq.~\ref{total_momentum_time_dt_sum} to get:
\begin{equation}
    P(t + \Delta t)  = (M(t) - \Delta m)(v(t) + \Delta v) + \Delta m (v(t) + v_{\rm exhaust})
    \label{total_momentum_time_dt_expanded}
\end{equation}

\section{Apply Conservation of Momentum}

Since we are considering a closed system in free space with no external forces, the total momentum of the system must be conserved. Therefore, the momentum at time $t$ must be equal to the momentum at time $t + \Delta t$:
\begin{equation}
    P(t) = P(t + \Delta t)
    \label{conservation_momentum}
\end{equation}
Substituting Eq.~\ref{initial_momentum} and Eq.~\ref{total_momentum_time_dt_sum} into Eq.~\ref{conservation_momentum}:
\begin{equation}
    M(t) v(t) = (M(t) - \Delta m)(v(t) + \Delta v) + \Delta m (v(t) + v_{\rm exhaust})
    \label{momentum_equality}
\end{equation}

\section{Simplify and Rearrange the Equation}

Expanding the right side of Eq.~\ref{momentum_equality} we get:
\begin{equation}
    M(t) v(t) = M(t)v(t) + M(t)\Delta v - \Delta m v(t) - \Delta m \Delta v + \Delta m v(t) + \Delta m v_{\rm exhaust}
    \label{expanded_momentum_equality_step1}
\end{equation}
Simplifying Eq.~\ref{expanded_momentum_equality_step1} by cancelling terms we get:
\begin{equation}
    M(t) v(t) = M(t)v(t) + M(t)\Delta v - \Delta m \Delta v + \Delta m v_{\rm exhaust}
    \label{expanded_momentum_equality_step2}
\end{equation}
Subtracting $M(t)v(t)$ from both sides of Eq.~\ref{expanded_momentum_equality_step2} gives:
\begin{equation}
    0 = M(t)\Delta v - \Delta m \Delta v + \Delta m v_{\rm exhaust}
    \label{simplified_momentum_equation_delta}
\end{equation}
We now consider the limit as $\Delta t \rightarrow 0$. In this limit, $\Delta m$ and $\Delta v$ become infinitesimally small, denoted by $dm$ and $dv$ respectively. The term $\Delta m \Delta v$ becomes a second-order infinitesimal and can be neglected compared to the first-order terms $M(t)\Delta v$ and $\Delta m v_{\rm exhaust}$.  Thus, in the limit, Eq.~\ref{simplified_momentum_equation_delta} becomes:
\begin{equation}
    0 = M(t)dv +  v_{\rm exhaust} dm
    \label{simplified_momentum_equation_differential}
\end{equation}
Rearranging Eq.~\ref{simplified_momentum_equation_differential} to solve for $dv$:
\begin{equation}
    M(t)dv = -v_{\rm exhaust} dm
    \label{rearranged_momentum_equation_dv}
\end{equation}
Dividing both sides of Eq.~\ref{rearranged_momentum_equation_dv} by $M(t)$ we get:
\begin{equation}
    dv = -v_{\rm exhaust} \frac{dm}{M(t)}
    \label{dv_equation_dm}
\end{equation}
Since $dm$ is the mass of fuel expelled, it represents a decrease in the rocket's mass. Therefore, the change in the rocket's mass, $dM$, is negative and equal to $-dm$, i.e., $dM = -dm$. Substituting $dm = -dM$ into Eq.~\ref{dv_equation_dm}:
\begin{equation}
    dv = -v_{\rm exhaust} \frac{-dM}{M(t)} = v_{\rm exhaust} \frac{dM}{M(t)}
    \label{dv_equation_dM}
\end{equation}
Note that if we take $v_{\rm exhaust}$ as the magnitude of the exhaust velocity (a positive value), and we consider the exhaust to be in the opposite direction of the rocket's motion, then the direction is accounted for by the negative sign in equation \eqref{rearranged_momentum_equation_dv}, making $dv$ positive when $dM$ is negative (mass decreases, velocity increases).  However, if we consider $v_{\rm exhaust}$ to be negative as initially defined (velocity relative to the rocket in the direction of rocket motion, and exhaust is in the opposite direction, so $v_{\rm exhaust} < 0$), then Eq.~\ref{dv_equation_dm} and \eqref{dv_equation_dM} still hold, and $dv$ will be positive for negative $v_{\rm exhaust}$ and negative $dM$. For clarity, let's assume $v_{\rm exhaust}$ is the magnitude of the exhaust velocity, so $v_{\rm exhaust} > 0$. Then we need to consider the direction explicitly. If the exhaust is in the opposite direction of the rocket's motion, we should write equation \eqref{rearranged_momentum_equation_dv} as $Mdv = v_{\rm exhaust} (-dm)$, where $v_{\rm exhaust}$ is now the magnitude, and $(-dm)$ is the mass expelled in the direction opposite to the rocket motion in the rocket frame.  Then $dv = -v_{\rm exhaust} \frac{dm}{M}$ (using $dm$ as positive mass expelled), and since $dM = -dm$, we get $dv = v_{\rm exhaust} \frac{dM}{M}$.

\section{Integrate to Find the Total Velocity Change}

To find the total change in velocity $\Delta v$ as the rocket mass changes from an initial mass $M_i$ to a final mass $M_f$, we integrate Eq.~\ref{dv_equation_dM}:
\begin{equation}
    \int_{v_i}^{v_f} dv = \int_{M_i}^{M_f} v_{\rm exhaust} \frac{dM}{M}
    \label{integral_dv_dM}
\end{equation}
Taking $v_{\rm exhaust}$ out of the integral in Eq.~\ref{integral_dv_dM} and evaluating the left integral, we get:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = v_f - v_i = v_{\rm exhaust} \int_{M_i}^{M_f} \frac{dM}{M}
    \label{delta_v_integral}
\end{equation}
The integral of $\frac{1}{M} dM$ is $\ln|M|$.
\begin{equation}
    \int \frac{1}{M} dM = \ln|M|
    \label{integral_1_over_M}
\end{equation}

Evaluating the definite integral in Eq.~\ref{delta_v_integral}:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = v_{\rm exhaust} [\ln|M|]_{M_i}^{M_f}
    \label{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step1}
\end{equation}
Evaluating the definite integral in Eq.~\ref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step1} we get:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v  = v_{\rm exhaust} (\ln|M_f| - \ln|M_i|)
    \label{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step2}
\end{equation}
Using the logarithm property from Eq.~\ref{logarithm_property}
\begin{equation}
    \ln(a) - \ln(b) = \ln\left(\frac{a}{b}\right)
    \label{logarithm_property}
\end{equation}
and applying it to Eq.~\ref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step2} we have:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = v_{\rm exhaust} \ln\left(\frac{M_f}{M_i}\right)
    \label{delta_v_log_ratio_step1}
\end{equation}
Using the property of logarithms and multiplying by $-1$ in Eq.~\ref{delta_v_log_ratio_step1} we get:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = -v_{\rm exhaust} \ln\left(\frac{M_f}{M_i}\right)
    \label{delta_v_negative_log}
\end{equation}
Using the property of logarithms and multiplying by $-1$ in Eq.~\ref{delta_v_negative_log} we get:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v =  v_{\rm exhaust} \ln\left(\frac{M_i}{M_f}\right)
    \label{rocket_equation_step1}
\end{equation}

\section{The Rocket Equation}

Equation \eqref{rocket_equation_step1} is the rocket equation. It expresses the change in velocity $\Delta v$ of a rocket as a function of the exhaust velocity $v_{\rm exhaust}$ and the ratio of the initial mass $M_i$ to the final mass $M_f$.

\textbf{Rocket Equation:}
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = v_{\rm exhaust} \ln\left(\frac{M_i}{M_f}\right)
    \label{rocket_equation_final}
\end{equation}

\section{Conclusion}

We have derived the rocket equation from first principles, starting with the conservation of momentum and considering a small mass of fuel being expelled over a small time interval. By considering the momentum of both the rocket and the exhaust gases before and after the expulsion, and then integrating the resulting differential equation, we arrived at the rocket equation. This equation highlights the key factors influencing a rocket's velocity change: the exhaust velocity and the mass ratio. A higher exhaust velocity and a larger mass ratio (meaning a larger proportion of initial mass is fuel) result in a greater achievable change in velocity. This equation is fundamental for space mission planning and rocket design.

\end{document}

thoughts

The user wants a Latex formatted list of all unique variables used in the provided Latex document. For each variable, I need to provide a description and a list of equation labels where the variable is used.

Here is a plan:

  1. Read through the Latex document and identify all variables.
  2. For each unique variable, write a description based on the context in the document.
  3. For each unique variable, identify all the equation labels where the variable is used.
  4. Format the output as a Latex list, where each item is a variable entry with description and equation references.

Let's start by identifying the variables and their descriptions and equation references.

  • $\Delta v$: change in velocity, used in (eq:new_velocity), (momentum_rocket_time_dt), (total_momentum_time_dt_expanded), (simplified_momentum_equation_delta), (delta_v_integral), (delta_v_evaluated_integral_step1), (delta_v_evaluated_integral_step2), (delta_v_log_ratio_step1), (delta_v_negative_log), (rocket_equation_step1), (rocket_equation_final)
  • $M(t)$: mass of the rocket at time $t$, used in (initial_momentum), (eq:mass_later), (momentum_rocket_time_dt), (total_momentum_time_dt_expanded), (expanded_momentum_equality_step1), (expanded_momentum_equality_step2), (simplified_momentum_equation_delta), (simplified_momentum_equation_differential), (rearranged_momentum_equation_dv), (dv_equation_dm), (dv_equation_dM)
  • $v(t)$: velocity of the rocket at time $t$, used in (initial_momentum), (eq:new_velocity), (eq:velocity_later), (momentum_rocket_time_dt), (momentum_exhaust_time_dt), (total_momentum_time_dt_expanded), (expanded_momentum_equality_step1), (expanded_momentum_equality_step2), (momentum_equality)
  • $P(t)$: momentum of the system at time $t$, used in (initial_momentum), (conservation_momentum), (momentum_equality)
  • $\Delta t$: small time interval, used in section title only
  • $\Delta m$: mass of fuel expelled during $\Delta t$, used in (eq:mass_later), (momentum_rocket_time_dt), (momentum_exhaust_time_dt), (total_momentum_time_dt_expanded), (expanded_momentum_equality_step1), (expanded_momentum_equality_step2), (simplified_momentum_equation_delta)
  • $v_{\rm exhaust}$: exhaust velocity relative to the rocket, used in (momentum_exhaust_time_dt), (total_momentum_time_dt_expanded), (expanded_momentum_equality_step1), (simplified_momentum_equation_delta), (simplified_momentum_equation_differential), (rearranged_momentum_equation_dv), (dv_equation_dm), (dv_equation_dM), (delta_v_integral), (delta_v_evaluated_integral_step1), (delta_v_evaluated_integral_step2), (delta_v_log_ratio_step1), (delta_v_negative_log), (rocket_equation_step1), (rocket_equation_final)
  • $P_{\text{rocket}}(t + \Delta t)$: momentum of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$, used in (momentum_rocket_time_dt), (total_momentum_time_dt_sum)
  • $P_{\text{exhaust}}(t + \Delta t)$: momentum of the exhaust gases at time $t + \Delta t$, used in (momentum_exhaust_time_dt), (total_momentum_time_dt_sum)
  • $P(t + \Delta t)$: total momentum at time $t + \Delta t$, used in (total_momentum_time_dt_sum), (total_momentum_time_dt_expanded), (conservation_momentum), (momentum_equality)
  • $M(t + \Delta t)$: mass of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$, used in (eq:mass_later), (momentum_rocket_time_dt)
  • $v(t + \Delta t)$: velocity of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$, used in (eq:new_velocity), (eq:velocity_later), (momentum_rocket_time_dt)
  • $dm$: infinitesimal mass of fuel expelled, used in (simplified_momentum_equation_differential), (rearranged_momentum_equation_dv), (dv_equation_dm)
  • $dv$: infinitesimal change in rocket velocity, used in (simplified_momentum_equation_differential), (rearranged_momentum_equation_dv), (dv_equation_dm), (dv_equation_dM), (integral_dv_dM)
  • $dM$: infinitesimal change in rocket mass, used in (dv_equation_dM)
  • $v_i$: initial velocity, used in (integral_dv_dM), (delta_v_integral)
  • $v_f$: final velocity, used in (integral_dv_dM), (delta_v_integral)
  • $M_i$: initial mass, used in (integral_dv_dM), (delta_v_integral), (delta_v_evaluated_integral_step1), (delta_v_evaluated_integral_step2), (delta_v_log_ratio_step1), (delta_v_negative_log), (rocket_equation_step1), (rocket_equation_final)
  • $M_f$: final mass, used in (integral_dv_dM), (delta_v_integral), (delta_v_evaluated_integral_step1), (delta_v_evaluated_integral_step2), (delta_v_log_ratio_step1), (delta_v_negative_log), (rocket_equation_step1), (rocket_equation_final)
  • $a$, $b$: variables used in logarithm property, used in (logarithm_property)

Let's refine the list and group similar variables.
Unique Variables:

  • $\Delta v$: Change in rocket velocity. Equations: \eqref{eq:new_velocity}, \eqref{momentum_rocket_time_dt}, \eqref{total_momentum_time_dt_expanded}, \eqref{simplified_momentum_equation_delta}, \eqref{delta_v_integral}, \eqref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step1}, \eqref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step2}, \eqref{delta_v_log_ratio_step1}, \eqref{delta_v_negative_log}, \eqref{rocket_equation_step1}, \eqref{rocket_equation_final}
  • $M(t)$: Mass of the rocket at time $t$. Equations: \eqref{initial_momentum}, \eqref{eq:mass_later}, \eqref{momentum_rocket_time_dt}, \eqref{total_momentum_time_dt_expanded}, \eqref{expanded_momentum_equality_step1}, \eqref{expanded_momentum_equality_step2}, \eqref{simplified_momentum_equation_delta}, \eqref{simplified_momentum_equation_differential}, \eqref{rearranged_momentum_equation_dv}, \eqref{dv_equation_dm}, \eqref{dv_equation_dM}
  • $v(t)$: Velocity of the rocket at time $t$. Equations: \eqref{initial_momentum}, \eqref{eq:new_velocity}, \eqref{eq:velocity_later}, \eqref{momentum_rocket_time_dt}, \eqref{momentum_exhaust_time_dt}, \eqref{total_momentum_time_dt_expanded}, \eqref{expanded_momentum_equality_step1}, \eqref{expanded_momentum_equality_step2}, \eqref{momentum_equality}
  • $P(t)$: Momentum of the system at time $t$. Equations: \eqref{initial_momentum}, \eqref{conservation_momentum}, \eqref{momentum_equality}
  • $\Delta m$: Mass of fuel expelled during time interval $\Delta t$. Equations: \eqref{eq:mass_later}, \eqref{momentum_rocket_time_dt}, \eqref{momentum_exhaust_time_dt}, \eqref{total_momentum_time_dt_expanded}, \eqref{expanded_momentum_equality_step1}, \eqref{simplified_momentum_equation_delta}
  • $v_{\rm exhaust}$: Exhaust velocity of the expelled gases relative to the rocket. Equations: \eqref{momentum_exhaust_time_dt}, \eqref{total_momentum_time_dt_expanded}, \eqref{expanded_momentum_equality_step1}, \eqref{simplified_momentum_equation_delta}, \eqref{simplified_momentum_equation_differential}, \eqref{rearranged_momentum_equation_dv}, \eqref{dv_equation_dm}, \eqref{dv_equation_dM}, \eqref{delta_v_integral}, \eqref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step1}, \eqref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step2}, \eqref{delta_v_log_ratio_step1}, \eqref{delta_v_negative_log}, \eqref{rocket_equation_step1}, \eqref{rocket_equation_final}
  • $P_{\text{rocket}}(t + \Delta t)$: Momentum of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$. Equations: \eqref{momentum_rocket_time_dt}, \eqref{total_momentum_time_dt_sum}
  • $P_{\text{exhaust}}(t + \Delta t)$: Momentum of the exhaust gases at time $t + \Delta t$. Equations: \eqref{momentum_exhaust_time_dt}, \eqref{total_momentum_time_dt_sum}
  • $P(t + \Delta t)$: Total momentum of the system at time $t + \Delta t$. Equations: \eqref{total_momentum_time_dt_sum}, \eqref{total_momentum_time_dt_expanded}, \eqref{conservation_momentum}, \eqref{momentum_equality}
  • $M(t + \Delta t)$: Mass of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$. Equations: \eqref{eq:mass_later}, \eqref{momentum_rocket_time_dt}
  • $v(t + \Delta t)$: Velocity of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$. Equations: \eqref{eq:new_velocity}, \eqref{eq:velocity_later}, \eqref{momentum_rocket_time_dt}
  • $dm$: Infinitesimal mass of fuel expelled. Equations: \eqref{simplified_momentum_equation_differential}, \eqref{rearranged_momentum_equation_dv}, \eqref{dv_equation_dm}
  • $dv$: Infinitesimal change in rocket velocity. Equations: \eqref{simplified_momentum_equation_differential}, \eqref{rearranged_momentum_equation_dv}, \eqref{dv_equation_dm}, \eqref{dv_equation_dM}, \eqref{integral_dv_dM}
  • $dM$: Infinitesimal change in rocket mass. Equations: \eqref{dv_equation_dM}
  • $v_i$: Initial rocket velocity. Equations: \eqref{integral_dv_dM}, \eqref{delta_v_integral}
  • $v_f$: Final rocket velocity. Equations: \eqref{integral_dv_dM}, \eqref{delta_v_integral}
  • $M_i$: Initial rocket mass. Equations: \eqref{integral_dv_dM}, \eqref{delta_v_integral}, \eqref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step1}, \eqref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step2}, \eqref{delta_v_log_ratio_step1}, \eqref{delta_v_negative_log}, \eqref{rocket_equation_step1}, \eqref{rocket_equation_final}
  • $M_f$: Final rocket mass. Equations: \eqref{integral_dv_dM}, \eqref{delta_v_integral}, \eqref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step1}, \eqref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step2}, \eqref{delta_v_log_ratio_step1}, \eqref{delta_v_negative_log}, \eqref{rocket_equation_step1}, \eqref{rocket_equation_final}

Now format it as a Latex list.

response

\begin{itemize}
    \item $\Delta v$: Change in rocket velocity. 
        Equations: \eqref{eq:new_velocity}, \eqref{momentum_rocket_time_dt}, \eqref{total_momentum_time_dt_expanded}, \eqref{simplified_momentum_equation_delta}, \eqref{delta_v_integral}, \eqref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step1}, \eqref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step2}, \eqref{delta_v_log_ratio_step1}, \eqref{delta_v_negative_log}, \eqref{rocket_equation_step1}, \eqref{rocket_equation_final}
    \item $M(t)$: Mass of the rocket at time $t$. 
        Equations: \eqref{initial_momentum}, \eqref{eq:mass_later}, \eqref{momentum_rocket_time_dt}, \eqref{total_momentum_time_dt_expanded}, \eqref{expanded_momentum_equality_step1}, \eqref{expanded_momentum_equality_step2}, \eqref{simplified_momentum_equation_delta}, \eqref{simplified_momentum_equation_differential}, \eqref{rearranged_momentum_equation_dv}, \eqref{dv_equation_dm}, \eqref{dv_equation_dM}
    \item $v(t)$: Velocity of the rocket at time $t$. 
        Equations: \eqref{initial_momentum}, \eqref{eq:new_velocity}, \eqref{eq:velocity_later}, \eqref{momentum_rocket_time_dt}, \eqref{momentum_exhaust_time_dt}, \eqref{total_momentum_time_dt_expanded}, \eqref{expanded_momentum_equality_step1}, \eqref{expanded_momentum_equality_step2}, \eqref{momentum_equality}
    \item $P(t)$: Momentum of the system (rocket and exhaust gases) at time $t$. 
        Equations: \eqref{initial_momentum}, \eqref{conservation_momentum}, \eqref{momentum_equality}
    \item $\Delta m$: Mass of fuel expelled as exhaust gases during the time interval $\Delta t$. 
        Equations: \eqref{eq:mass_later}, \eqref{momentum_rocket_time_dt}, \eqref{momentum_exhaust_time_dt}, \eqref{total_momentum_time_dt_expanded}, \eqref{expanded_momentum_equality_step1}, \eqref{simplified_momentum_equation_delta}
    \item $v_{\rm exhaust}$: Exhaust velocity of the expelled gases relative to the rocket. 
        Equations: \eqref{momentum_exhaust_time_dt}, \eqref{total_momentum_time_dt_expanded}, \eqref{expanded_momentum_equality_step1}, \eqref{simplified_momentum_equation_delta}, \eqref{simplified_momentum_equation_differential}, \eqref{rearranged_momentum_equation_dv}, \eqref{dv_equation_dm}, \eqref{dv_equation_dM}, \eqref{delta_v_integral}, \eqref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step1}, \eqref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step2}, \eqref{delta_v_log_ratio_step1}, \eqref{delta_v_negative_log}, \eqref{rocket_equation_step1}, \eqref{rocket_equation_final}
    \item $P_{\text{rocket}}(t + \Delta t)$: Momentum of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$. 
        Equations: \eqref{momentum_rocket_time_dt}, \eqref{total_momentum_time_dt_sum}
    \item $P_{\text{exhaust}}(t + \Delta t)$: Momentum of the exhaust gases at time $t + \Delta t$. 
        Equations: \eqref{momentum_exhaust_time_dt}, \eqref{total_momentum_time_dt_sum}
    \item $P(t + \Delta t)$: Total momentum of the system at time $t + \Delta t$. 
        Equations: \eqref{total_momentum_time_dt_sum}, \eqref{total_momentum_time_dt_expanded}, \eqref{conservation_momentum}, \eqref{momentum_equality}
    \item $M(t + \Delta t)$: Mass of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$. 
        Equations: \eqref{eq:mass_later}, \eqref{momentum_rocket_time_dt}
    \item $v(t + \Delta t)$: Velocity of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$. 
        Equations: \eqref{eq:new_velocity}, \eqref{eq:velocity_later}, \eqref{momentum_rocket_time_dt}
    \item $dm$: Infinitesimal mass of fuel expelled. 
        Equations: \eqref{simplified_momentum_equation_differential}, \eqref{rearranged_momentum_equation_dv}, \eqref{dv_equation_dm}
    \item $dv$: Infinitesimal change in rocket velocity. 
        Equations: \eqref{simplified_momentum_equation_differential}, \eqref{rearranged_momentum_equation_dv}, \eqref{dv_equation_dm}, \eqref{dv_equation_dM}, \eqref{integral_dv_dM}
    \item $dM$: Infinitesimal change in rocket mass. 
        Equations: \eqref{dv_equation_dM}
    \item $v_i$: Initial rocket velocity. 
        Equations: \eqref{integral_dv_dM}, \eqref{delta_v_integral}
    \item $v_f$: Final rocket velocity. 
        Equations: \eqref{integral_dv_dM}, \eqref{delta_v_integral}
    \item $M_i$: Initial rocket mass. 
        Equations: \eqref{integral_dv_dM}, \eqref{delta_v_integral}, \eqref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step1}, \eqref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step2}, \eqref{delta_v_log_ratio_step1}, \eqref{delta_v_negative_log}, \eqref{rocket_equation_step1}, \eqref{rocket_equation_final}
    \item $M_f$: Final rocket mass. 
        Equations: \eqref{integral_dv_dM}, \eqref{delta_v_integral}, \eqref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step1}, \eqref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step2}, \eqref{delta_v_log_ratio_step1}, \eqref{delta_v_negative_log}, \eqref{rocket_equation_step1}, \eqref{rocket_equation_final}
\end{itemize}

@bhpayne
Copy link
Member Author

bhpayne commented Jan 28, 2025

Consolidated Latex file:

\documentclass{article}
\usepackage{amsmath}
%\usepackage{amsfonts}
%\usepackage{amssymb}

% margins of 1 inch:
\setlength{\topmargin}{-.5in}
\setlength{\textheight}{9in}
\setlength{\oddsidemargin}{0in}
\setlength{\textwidth}{6.5in}

\usepackage[pdftex]{hyperref} % hyperlink equation and bibliographic citations

\title{Derivation of the Rocket Equation from First Principles}
\author{Ben Payne, with Gemini 2.0}
\date{\today}

\begin{document}
\maketitle

\section{Variables used in Derivation}


\begin{itemize}
    \item $\Delta v$: Change in rocket velocity. 
        Equations: \eqref{eq:new_velocity}, \eqref{momentum_rocket_time_dt}, \eqref{total_momentum_time_dt_expanded}, \eqref{simplified_momentum_equation_delta}, \eqref{delta_v_integral}, \eqref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step1}, \eqref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step2}, \eqref{delta_v_log_ratio_step1}, \eqref{delta_v_negative_log}, \eqref{rocket_equation_step1}, \eqref{rocket_equation_final}
    \item $M(t)$: Mass of the rocket at time $t$. 
        Equations: \eqref{initial_momentum}, \eqref{eq:mass_later}, \eqref{momentum_rocket_time_dt}, \eqref{total_momentum_time_dt_expanded}, \eqref{expanded_momentum_equality_step1}, \eqref{expanded_momentum_equality_step2}, \eqref{simplified_momentum_equation_delta}, \eqref{simplified_momentum_equation_differential}, \eqref{rearranged_momentum_equation_dv}, \eqref{dv_equation_dm}, \eqref{dv_equation_dM}
    \item $v(t)$: Velocity of the rocket at time $t$. 
        Equations: \eqref{initial_momentum}, \eqref{eq:new_velocity}, \eqref{eq:velocity_later}, \eqref{momentum_rocket_time_dt}, \eqref{momentum_exhaust_time_dt}, \eqref{total_momentum_time_dt_expanded}, \eqref{expanded_momentum_equality_step1}, \eqref{expanded_momentum_equality_step2}, \eqref{momentum_equality}
    \item $P(t)$: Momentum of the system (rocket and exhaust gases) at time $t$. 
        Equations: \eqref{initial_momentum}, \eqref{conservation_momentum}, \eqref{momentum_equality}
    \item $\Delta m$: Mass of fuel expelled as exhaust gases during the time interval $\Delta t$. 
        Equations: \eqref{eq:mass_later}, \eqref{momentum_rocket_time_dt}, \eqref{momentum_exhaust_time_dt}, \eqref{total_momentum_time_dt_expanded}, \eqref{expanded_momentum_equality_step1}, \eqref{simplified_momentum_equation_delta}
    \item $v_{\rm exhaust}$: Exhaust velocity of the expelled gases relative to the rocket. 
        Equations: \eqref{momentum_exhaust_time_dt}, \eqref{total_momentum_time_dt_expanded}, \eqref{expanded_momentum_equality_step1}, \eqref{simplified_momentum_equation_delta}, \eqref{simplified_momentum_equation_differential}, \eqref{rearranged_momentum_equation_dv}, \eqref{dv_equation_dm}, \eqref{dv_equation_dM}, \eqref{delta_v_integral}, \eqref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step1}, \eqref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step2}, \eqref{delta_v_log_ratio_step1}, \eqref{delta_v_negative_log}, \eqref{rocket_equation_step1}, \eqref{rocket_equation_final}
    \item $P_{\text{rocket}}(t + \Delta t)$: Momentum of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$. 
        Equations: \eqref{momentum_rocket_time_dt}, \eqref{total_momentum_time_dt_sum}
    \item $P_{\text{exhaust}}(t + \Delta t)$: Momentum of the exhaust gases at time $t + \Delta t$. 
        Equations: \eqref{momentum_exhaust_time_dt}, \eqref{total_momentum_time_dt_sum}
    \item $P(t + \Delta t)$: Total momentum of the system at time $t + \Delta t$. 
        Equations: \eqref{total_momentum_time_dt_sum}, \eqref{total_momentum_time_dt_expanded}, \eqref{conservation_momentum}, \eqref{momentum_equality}
    \item $M(t + \Delta t)$: Mass of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$. 
        Equations: \eqref{eq:mass_later}, \eqref{momentum_rocket_time_dt}
    \item $v(t + \Delta t)$: Velocity of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$. 
        Equations: \eqref{eq:new_velocity}, \eqref{eq:velocity_later}, \eqref{momentum_rocket_time_dt}
    \item $dm$: Infinitesimal mass of fuel expelled. 
        Equations: \eqref{simplified_momentum_equation_differential}, \eqref{rearranged_momentum_equation_dv}, \eqref{dv_equation_dm}
    \item $dv$: Infinitesimal change in rocket velocity. 
        Equations: \eqref{simplified_momentum_equation_differential}, \eqref{rearranged_momentum_equation_dv}, \eqref{dv_equation_dm}, \eqref{dv_equation_dM}, \eqref{integral_dv_dM}
    \item $dM$: Infinitesimal change in rocket mass. 
        Equations: \eqref{dv_equation_dM}
    \item $v_i$: Initial rocket velocity. 
        Equations: \eqref{integral_dv_dM}, \eqref{delta_v_integral}
    \item $v_f$: Final rocket velocity. 
        Equations: \eqref{integral_dv_dM}, \eqref{delta_v_integral}
    \item $M_i$: Initial rocket mass. 
        Equations: \eqref{integral_dv_dM}, \eqref{delta_v_integral}, \eqref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step1}, \eqref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step2}, \eqref{delta_v_log_ratio_step1}, \eqref{delta_v_negative_log}, \eqref{rocket_equation_step1}, \eqref{rocket_equation_final}
    \item $M_f$: Final rocket mass. 
        Equations: \eqref{integral_dv_dM}, \eqref{delta_v_integral}, \eqref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step1}, \eqref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step2}, \eqref{delta_v_log_ratio_step1}, \eqref{delta_v_negative_log}, \eqref{rocket_equation_step1}, \eqref{rocket_equation_final}
\end{itemize}


\section{Introduction}

The rocket equation, also known as the Tsiolkovsky rocket equation, is a fundamental relationship in astronautics that describes the change in velocity ($\Delta v$) a rocket can achieve based on its exhaust velocity and the ratio of its initial and final mass. This derivation starts from first principles, specifically Newton's second law and the conservation of momentum, to arrive at this crucial equation. We will meticulously detail each step and the reasoning behind it.

\section{Define the System and Initial Conditions}

Consider a rocket in free space, far from any gravitational fields or atmospheric drag. This simplifies our analysis by eliminating external forces. We define our system as the rocket \textit{and} the exhaust gases expelled from it. This is crucial for applying the principle of conservation of momentum, as momentum is conserved for a closed system.

At an initial time $t$, let's define the following quantities:
\begin{itemize}
    \item $M(t)$: The mass of the rocket at time $t$. This includes the mass of the rocket structure and the remaining fuel.
    \item $v(t)$: The velocity of the rocket at time $t$ with respect to an inertial reference frame. We will consider motion in one dimension for simplicity, and treat velocity as a scalar.
\end{itemize}
The initial momentum of the system at time $t$, $P(t)$, is simply the momentum of the rocket, as the exhaust gases are initially part of the rocket and moving with it.
\begin{equation}
    P(t) = M(t) v(t)
    \label{initial_momentum}
\end{equation}

\section{Consider a Small Time Interval \texorpdfstring{$\Delta t$}{Delta t}}

Now, consider a small time interval $\Delta t$. During this interval, the rocket expels a small amount of fuel as exhaust gases. We define the following changes and quantities during this interval:
\begin{itemize}
    \item $\Delta m$: The mass of fuel expelled as exhaust gases during the time interval $\Delta t$. Note that $\Delta m$ is a positive quantity.
    \item $\Delta v$: The change in the rocket's velocity during the time interval $\Delta t$. The new velocity of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$ will be
\begin{equation}
    v(t + \Delta t) = v(t) + \Delta v
    \label{eq:new_velocity}
\end{equation}
    
    \item $v_{\rm exhaust}$: The exhaust velocity of the expelled gases \textit{relative to the rocket}. We assume this exhaust velocity is constant throughout the burn for simplicity.  If the exhaust is directed opposite to the rocket's motion, $v_{\rm exhaust}$ will be negative in our chosen coordinate system (where the positive direction is the direction of the rocket's velocity). However, for the derivation, we will consider $v_{\rm exhaust}$ as the magnitude of the exhaust velocity and explicitly consider its direction in our momentum calculations. Let's consider $v_{\rm exhaust}$ to be directed opposite to the rocket's velocity, so it will be negative.
\end{itemize}

\section{Calculate the Momentum at Time \texorpdfstring{$t+\Delta t$}{t+Delta t}}

At time $t + \Delta t$, we have two components to consider for the momentum of our system: the rocket itself (now with reduced mass and changed velocity) and the expelled exhaust gases.

\subsection{Momentum of the Rocket at \texorpdfstring{$t+\Delta t$}{t+Delta t}}
The mass of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$ is 
\begin{equation}
    M(t + \Delta t) = M(t) - \Delta m
    \label{eq:mass_later}
\end{equation}
The velocity of the rocket at time $t + \Delta t$ is
\begin{equation}
 v(t + \Delta t) = v(t) + \Delta v
    \label{eq:velocity_later}
\end{equation}
Therefore, the momentum of the rocket at $t + \Delta t$ is:
\begin{equation}
    P_{\text{rocket}}(t + \Delta t) = (M(t) - \Delta m)(v(t) + \Delta v)
    \label{momentum_rocket_time_dt}
\end{equation}

\subsection{Momentum of the Exhaust Gases at \texorpdfstring{$t+\Delta t$}{t+Delta t}}
We need to find the velocity of the exhaust gases with respect to our inertial reference frame. The exhaust velocity $v_{\rm exhaust}$ is given relative to the rocket.  Since the rocket's velocity at time $t$ is $v(t)$, and the exhaust is directed opposite to the rocket's motion (in the rocket's frame), the velocity of the exhaust gases in the inertial frame is $v(t) + v_{\rm exhaust}$.  Since $v_{\rm exhaust}$ is negative (opposite to the rocket's velocity), this effectively means the exhaust gas velocity in the inertial frame is $v(t) - |v_{\rm exhaust}|$ if we consider $|v_{\rm exhaust}|$ as the magnitude of exhaust velocity.  However, keeping $v_{\rm exhaust}$ as negative exhaust velocity relative to the rocket in the direction of the rocket's motion simplifies the notation. So, the velocity of the exhaust gases in the inertial frame is $v(t) + v_{\rm exhaust}$. The mass of the exhaust gases is $\Delta m$. Therefore, the momentum of the exhaust gases at $t + \Delta t$ is:
\begin{equation}
    P_{\text{exhaust}}(t + \Delta t) = \Delta m (v(t) + v_{\rm exhaust})
    \label{momentum_exhaust_time_dt}
\end{equation}

\subsection{Total Momentum at \texorpdfstring{$t+\Delta t$}{t+Delta t}}
The total momentum of the system at time $t + \Delta t$ is the sum of the momentum of the rocket and the momentum of the exhaust gases:
\begin{equation}
    P(t + \Delta t) = P_{\text{rocket}}(t + \Delta t) + P_{\text{exhaust}}(t + \Delta t)
    \label{total_momentum_time_dt_sum}
\end{equation}
Substituting Eq.~\ref{momentum_rocket_time_dt} and Eq.~\ref{momentum_exhaust_time_dt} into Eq.~\ref{total_momentum_time_dt_sum} to get:
\begin{equation}
    P(t + \Delta t)  = (M(t) - \Delta m)(v(t) + \Delta v) + \Delta m (v(t) + v_{\rm exhaust})
    \label{total_momentum_time_dt_expanded}
\end{equation}

\section{Apply Conservation of Momentum}

Since we are considering a closed system in free space with no external forces, the total momentum of the system must be conserved. Therefore, the momentum at time $t$ must be equal to the momentum at time $t + \Delta t$:
\begin{equation}
    P(t) = P(t + \Delta t)
    \label{conservation_momentum}
\end{equation}
Substituting Eq.~\ref{initial_momentum} and Eq.~\ref{total_momentum_time_dt_sum} into Eq.~\ref{conservation_momentum}:
\begin{equation}
    M(t) v(t) = (M(t) - \Delta m)(v(t) + \Delta v) + \Delta m (v(t) + v_{\rm exhaust})
    \label{momentum_equality}
\end{equation}

\section{Simplify and Rearrange the Equation}

Expanding the right side of Eq.~\ref{momentum_equality} we get:
\begin{equation}
    M(t) v(t) = M(t)v(t) + M(t)\Delta v - \Delta m v(t) - \Delta m \Delta v + \Delta m v(t) + \Delta m v_{\rm exhaust}
    \label{expanded_momentum_equality_step1}
\end{equation}
Simplifying Eq.~\ref{expanded_momentum_equality_step1} by cancelling terms we get:
\begin{equation}
    M(t) v(t) = M(t)v(t) + M(t)\Delta v - \Delta m \Delta v + \Delta m v_{\rm exhaust}
    \label{expanded_momentum_equality_step2}
\end{equation}
Subtracting $M(t)v(t)$ from both sides of Eq.~\ref{expanded_momentum_equality_step2} gives:
\begin{equation}
    0 = M(t)\Delta v - \Delta m \Delta v + \Delta m v_{\rm exhaust}
    \label{simplified_momentum_equation_delta}
\end{equation}
We now consider the limit as $\Delta t \rightarrow 0$. In this limit, $\Delta m$ and $\Delta v$ become infinitesimally small, denoted by $dm$ and $dv$ respectively. The term $\Delta m \Delta v$ becomes a second-order infinitesimal and can be neglected compared to the first-order terms $M(t)\Delta v$ and $\Delta m v_{\rm exhaust}$.  Thus, in the limit, Eq.~\ref{simplified_momentum_equation_delta} becomes:
\begin{equation}
    0 = M(t)dv +  v_{\rm exhaust} dm
    \label{simplified_momentum_equation_differential}
\end{equation}
Rearranging Eq.~\ref{simplified_momentum_equation_differential} to solve for $dv$:
\begin{equation}
    M(t)dv = -v_{\rm exhaust} dm
    \label{rearranged_momentum_equation_dv}
\end{equation}
Dividing both sides of Eq.~\ref{rearranged_momentum_equation_dv} by $M(t)$ we get:
\begin{equation}
    dv = -v_{\rm exhaust} \frac{dm}{M(t)}
    \label{dv_equation_dm}
\end{equation}
Since $dm$ is the mass of fuel expelled, it represents a decrease in the rocket's mass. Therefore, the change in the rocket's mass, $dM$, is negative and equal to $-dm$, i.e., $dM = -dm$. Substituting $dm = -dM$ into Eq.~\ref{dv_equation_dm}:
\begin{equation}
    dv = -v_{\rm exhaust} \frac{-dM}{M(t)} = v_{\rm exhaust} \frac{dM}{M(t)}
    \label{dv_equation_dM}
\end{equation}
Note that if we take $v_{\rm exhaust}$ as the magnitude of the exhaust velocity (a positive value), and we consider the exhaust to be in the opposite direction of the rocket's motion, then the direction is accounted for by the negative sign in equation \eqref{rearranged_momentum_equation_dv}, making $dv$ positive when $dM$ is negative (mass decreases, velocity increases).  However, if we consider $v_{\rm exhaust}$ to be negative as initially defined (velocity relative to the rocket in the direction of rocket motion, and exhaust is in the opposite direction, so $v_{\rm exhaust} < 0$), then Eq.~\ref{dv_equation_dm} and \eqref{dv_equation_dM} still hold, and $dv$ will be positive for negative $v_{\rm exhaust}$ and negative $dM$. For clarity, let's assume $v_{\rm exhaust}$ is the magnitude of the exhaust velocity, so $v_{\rm exhaust} > 0$. Then we need to consider the direction explicitly. If the exhaust is in the opposite direction of the rocket's motion, we should write equation \eqref{rearranged_momentum_equation_dv} as $Mdv = v_{\rm exhaust} (-dm)$, where $v_{\rm exhaust}$ is now the magnitude, and $(-dm)$ is the mass expelled in the direction opposite to the rocket motion in the rocket frame.  Then $dv = -v_{\rm exhaust} \frac{dm}{M}$ (using $dm$ as positive mass expelled), and since $dM = -dm$, we get $dv = v_{\rm exhaust} \frac{dM}{M}$.

\section{Integrate to Find the Total Velocity Change}

To find the total change in velocity $\Delta v$ as the rocket mass changes from an initial mass $M_i$ to a final mass $M_f$, we integrate Eq.~\ref{dv_equation_dM}:
\begin{equation}
    \int_{v_i}^{v_f} dv = \int_{M_i}^{M_f} v_{\rm exhaust} \frac{dM}{M}
    \label{integral_dv_dM}
\end{equation}
Taking $v_{\rm exhaust}$ out of the integral in Eq.~\ref{integral_dv_dM} and evaluating the left integral, we get:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = v_f - v_i = v_{\rm exhaust} \int_{M_i}^{M_f} \frac{dM}{M}
    \label{delta_v_integral}
\end{equation}
The integral of $\frac{1}{M} dM$ is $\ln|M|$.
\begin{equation}
    \int \frac{1}{M} dM = \ln|M|
    \label{integral_1_over_M}
\end{equation}

Evaluating the definite integral in Eq.~\ref{delta_v_integral}:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = v_{\rm exhaust} [\ln|M|]_{M_i}^{M_f}
    \label{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step1}
\end{equation}
Evaluating the definite integral in Eq.~\ref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step1} we get:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v  = v_{\rm exhaust} (\ln|M_f| - \ln|M_i|)
    \label{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step2}
\end{equation}
Using the logarithm property from Eq.~\ref{logarithm_property}
\begin{equation}
    \ln(a) - \ln(b) = \ln\left(\frac{a}{b}\right)
    \label{logarithm_property}
\end{equation}
and applying it to Eq.~\ref{delta_v_evaluated_integral_step2} we have:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = v_{\rm exhaust} \ln\left(\frac{M_f}{M_i}\right)
    \label{delta_v_log_ratio_step1}
\end{equation}
Using the property of logarithms and multiplying by $-1$ in Eq.~\ref{delta_v_log_ratio_step1} we get:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = -v_{\rm exhaust} \ln\left(\frac{M_f}{M_i}\right)
    \label{delta_v_negative_log}
\end{equation}
Using the property of logarithms and multiplying by $-1$ in Eq.~\ref{delta_v_negative_log} we get:
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v =  v_{\rm exhaust} \ln\left(\frac{M_i}{M_f}\right)
    \label{rocket_equation_step1}
\end{equation}

\section{The Rocket Equation}

Equation \eqref{rocket_equation_step1} is the rocket equation. It expresses the change in velocity $\Delta v$ of a rocket as a function of the exhaust velocity $v_{\rm exhaust}$ and the ratio of the initial mass $M_i$ to the final mass $M_f$.

\textbf{Rocket Equation:}
\begin{equation}
    \Delta v = v_{\rm exhaust} \ln\left(\frac{M_i}{M_f}\right)
    \label{rocket_equation_final}
\end{equation}

\section{Conclusion}

We have derived the rocket equation from first principles, starting with the conservation of momentum and considering a small mass of fuel being expelled over a small time interval. By considering the momentum of both the rocket and the exhaust gases before and after the expulsion, and then integrating the resulting differential equation, we arrived at the rocket equation. This equation highlights the key factors influencing a rocket's velocity change: the exhaust velocity and the mass ratio. A higher exhaust velocity and a larger mass ratio (meaning a larger proportion of initial mass is fuel) result in a greater achievable change in velocity. This equation is fundamental for space mission planning and rocket design.

\end{document}

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Projects
Status: No status
Development

No branches or pull requests

1 participant