Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

post/guide_to_modis_aerosol_product/ #9

Open
utterances-bot opened this issue Jun 7, 2022 · 4 comments
Open

post/guide_to_modis_aerosol_product/ #9

utterances-bot opened this issue Jun 7, 2022 · 4 comments

Comments

@utterances-bot
Copy link

MODIS 二级气溶胶产品指北(with Python) - 炸鸡人博客

A minimal Hugo theme with nice theme color.

https://zhajiman.github.io/post/guide_to_modis_aerosol_product/

Copy link

imutum commented Jun 7, 2022

- 对于陆面,当 NDVI < 0.2,即植被稀疏时,采用 QA_DB > 1 的 DB AOD;当 NDVI > 0.3,即植被茂密时,采用 QA_DT = 3 的 DT-land AOD;

这一块有误哈,应当是只有在0.2~0.3时才使用较高的可信度的检索,在这之外使用全部等级的对应算法的数据,对应的文献链接。从数据文件里也能佐证这点,联合数据的质量标识从0~3都有,并不是缺了1。

在目前最新的 C6.1,没有改变该处。

Copy link
Owner

ZhaJiMan commented Jun 8, 2022

看了一下这篇论文,确实表示只在 NDVI 处于过渡范围内才对反演的 QA 有要求,且联合的 QA 里 0~3 都有值。但是如果你画图会发现,combined 的图相比 DT 和 DB 的图,会缺失低 QA 的部分。并且通过数组的 Boolean 索引也会看到,陆面上不存在 QA=1 的 AOD,你说的 1 其实是来自洋面的部分。所以我仍然维持原结论,不过目前只测试了文中的那个文件,所以也不能百分百肯定。

Copy link

imutum commented Jun 22, 2022

还是那篇文献,之前看的有疏漏:

Because of the over-land focus of this study, the term DT is used hereafter to refer to only the over-land algorithm.
...
The merged SDS is only populated for those pixels where the appropriate algorithm's retrieval is assigned a sufficiently high QA flag to be deemed usable by the algorithm team (QA≥2 for DB, QA=3 for DT, QA≥1 for ocean).

陆地上DT确实只有QA=3的AOD。共勉

Copy link
Owner

好吧,我主要参考的是这篇,而你那篇文献确实直接指出了陆面的质量要求,我看的时候也看漏了😂

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

3 participants